Gerry Hutch The Bullet Proof Monk 

With INL News Corporation's Website Tonight Website Builder For Dummies It Is So Easy And Cheap To Own You Own Domain Name for as low as $5 And Build Your Own Website for As Low As $2 a week

Click Here for INL News Amazon Best Seller Books

INLNewsLimitedCorporateLogo

The Monk A Free Man P 1 of 6

The Monk A Free Man P 2  of 6

The Monk A Free Man P 3 of 6

The Monk A Free Man P4 of 6

The Monk A Free Man P 5 of 6

The Monk A Free Man P 6 of 6

 

Gerry-The-Monk-Hutch

Gerry-The-Monk-Hutch

The Monk A Free Man 

mmmmm

INLNewsLimitedCorporateLogo
 
 
 
Dublin Regency Shooting In Ireland Video One

GerryHutchTheBulletProofMonk

Gerard Hutch (born 11 April 1963) is an Irish criminal. He was the prime suspect for two of the biggest armed robberies in Irish history.

Known for leading a "disciplined, ascetic lifestyle" since leaving prison in 1985, he was nicknamed "The Monk" by investigative journalist Veronica Guerin.

Gerry Hutch is also the leader of the organized crime group the Hutch Gang, and was charged but acquitted of the murder of David Byrne.

Gerry The 'Monk' Hutch The Double Cross Part 1  

Gerry Hutch's Involvement in Robberies

Born in central Dublin on 11 April 1963, his criminal career began at the age of 10.  At some point in the 1970s, Hutch joined the Bugsy Malone Gang of inner city youngsters (named for the Bugsy Malone film), which he later led, and whose crimes included "jump-overs" - jumping over bank counters, grabbing cash and running.

He was later part of a gang involved in major robberies and received many convictions between 1970 and 1983 intermittently spending time in prison. His gang was said to have amassed an estimated IR£40 million from a series of bank robberies, jewellery heists, and fraud scams spanning almost eight years.

Hutch admitted to being a "convicted criminal" in a 2008 interview with The Independent, but insisted that he made his money through property deals, not crime.

Gerard Hutch is an Irish criminal. He was the prime suspect for two of the biggest armed robberies in Irish history. Known for leading a "disciplined, ascetic lifestyle" since leaving prison in 1985, he was nicknamed "The Monk" by investigative journalist Veronica Guerin. Hutch is also the leader of the organized crime group the Hutch Gang, and was charged but acquitted of the murder of David Byrne.

GerryHutchTheBulletProofMonk

Gerry Hutch The Bullet Proof Monk

Gerry Hutch's Murder Charge

In April 2021, he became the subject of a European Arrest Warrant as Gardaí said they had enough evidence to charge him with murder in connection with the shooting of David Byrne.

The EAW was issued after the Director for Public Prosecutions moved that he be charged with murder and tried before the Special Criminal Court. Gerry Hutch is also likely to face other charges, such as attempted murder and possession of firearms. 

An investigation file was submitted by Garda detectives based in Ballymun to the DPP late in 2020. He was arrested in Spain in August 2021

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch The Education Of A Criminal Part 2

Gerard "Gerry" Hutch is an Irish criminal. He was the prime suspect for two of the biggest armed robberies in Irish history. Known for leading a "disciplined, ascetic lifestyle" since leaving prison in 1985, he was nicknamed " The Monk " by Veronica Guerin, an investigative journalist who was assassinated in 1996.

GerryHutchTheBulletProofMonk

Gerry Hutch The Bullet Proof Monk 

Gerry 'Monk' Hutch Story Part 3 The Dublin Underworld

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after not guilty verdict in Regency Hotel murder trial

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after not guilty verdict in Regency Hotel murder trial

Gerry' The Monk' Hutch Story Part 4  The Trial Of The Century

"Gerry Hutch, The Bullet Proof Monk" -  the film

An INL News Group's Special Investigation Team formed to investigate the gang war that broke out a few years ago between the Hutch Crime Organisation and the international  Kinahan Transnational Criminal Organisation  (KTCO) is working with film screen play writers to write a film screen play and produce a film called

                         "Gerry Hutch, The Bullet Proof Monk"

Extradition and charge

On 29 September 2021 he was extradited to Ireland, flown in a military CASA 235 from Madrid to Casement Aerodrome by the Irish Defence Forces.  He was then taken to the Criminal Courts of Justice under armed Garda escort where he was charged with the murder of David Byrne before the Special Criminal Court. He was remanded in custody until 15 October at 10:30am. Other co-accused are to stand trial on 3 October 2022 and the state solicitor asked that he come in on that date, to which the three judges agreed.

Both Hutch and Jonathan Dowdall, who is also charged with the murder, claimed in judicial review before the High Court that trial before the Special Criminal Court would be unlawful and a breach of their fundamental rights because the court was acting as a permanent institution after being established on a temporary basis. These were dismissed by Mr Anthony Barr, who ruled that the legislation was neither temporary nor had any temporal limit. Both Hutch and Dowdall sought leave to appeal the High Court decision to the Supreme Court. On 5 May 2022 a panel reserved judgement in both cases.  After a request from counsel for the Attorney General, the case was adjourned until 1 July 2022, pending the Supreme Court decision.

The trial began in October 2022.

On 17 April 2023, Hutch was found not guilty.

On 21 April 2023, an investigator with the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission resigned after allegations the officer had attended the same party as Hutch on the 19 April

images/DanielKinahan-left-GerryHutch-right

Daniel Kinahan the  boss of  the international  Kinahan Transnational Criminal Organisation  (KTCO) -left

and Gerry Hutch-right...

Gerry Hutch's Legal Issues

In 1999, in the course of court proceedings brought against Hutch by the Irish state's anti-money laundering agency, the Criminal Assets Bureau (CAB), Detective Chief Superintendent Felix McKenna stated that Hutch had been involved in the IR£1.7 million robbery of an armoured van at Marino Mart in January 1987 and the £3 million armed robbery of a Brinks Allied Security Depot in Clonshaugh, County Dublin, in 1995, which had been the largest cash robbery in the State at the time.

Hutch eventually reached an £1.2m settlement with the CAB to "cover back taxes and interest for a nine-year period".

Hutch has also been awarded money from legal actions in Irish courts. These included £8,500 won from Securicor Ireland in June 1991, £2,000 from the Sunday Tribune newspaper in a libel action and around £26,000 won in legal actions against the Irish state.

In 2014, Hutch's Wikipedia article was one of the first pages requested for removal under the European Union's Right to be Forgotten Act. This required search engines, such as Google, to remove links to the Wikipedia article from their search results. The Wikimedia Foundation does not know who requested this removal. 

 Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales described the act as "deeply immoral"

Film and Television

Hutch is depicted in the film Veronica Guerin, played by Alan Devine. It is based on the life of the late Irish journalist Veronica Guerin who had interviewed him.

Hutch appeared on RTÉ's Prime Time programme in March 2008 where he was interviewed about his life and criminal career. Hutch denied any criminal activity, since his last prison sentence, other than tax evasion.

Hutch was the subject of investigation in the Irish TV3 channel's television series, Dirty Money. Episode 5, which aired March 2008 was solely devoted to the assets seized by the CAB from Hutch and the threat to seize assets from his family

Gerry Hutch's Personal and Family Life

Gerry Hutch is the leader of the Hutch Gang, an organized crime group that includes members of his family. He is an uncle of Gary Hutch, who was shot dead in September 2015 near MarbellaAndalusiaSpain. His brother Eddie Hutch Snr. was shot dead in North Strand Dublin in February 2016. These killings are part of the Hutch-Kinahan feud between Hutch and the rival Kinahan family.

In 1998 he was a founding member of the Corinthians Boxing Club in Dublin and has served as treasurer for the club. The club has a full gym and a boxing ring. The latter was donated by film director Jim Sheridan after making the film The Boxer

After the CAB settlement in 1999, Hutch applied for and was granted a taxi licence, and set up the limousine service Carry Any Body. The name is a humorous reference to the Criminal Assets Bureau.  He has featured in the Irish media as he has driven celebrities  including Mike Tyson on their visits to Ireland.

Gerry Hutch - Wikipedia

References[edit]

  1. ^ Martin Breheny (1 July 2000). "Hitting them where it hurts"Independent. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  2. Jump up to:a b Paul Williams (2011). Badfellas. Penguin. pp. 243–45. ISBN 9780141970295. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  3. Jump up to:a b c d e f g Keane, Conor (1 April 2000). "Hutch to Clear Outstanding Liabilities in a £1.2m Deal with the State"Irish Examiner. Archived from the original on 27 February 2007. Retrieved 29 September 2010.
  4. ^ Henry McDonald (7 February 2016). "Murders in Spain, and a Dublin attack with AK-47s: the deadly 20-year war of Ireland's drug cartels"The Guardian. Retrieved 20 February 2016.
  5. ^ Vikram Dodd (7 December 2000). "Journalist 'was killed to save drugs empire'"The Guardian. Retrieved 20 February 2016.
  6. ^ "Gerry Hutch at 60: The Monk's rise through the criminal underworld and how his retirement plans fell to pieces"www.independent.ie. Retrieved 30 April 2023.
  7. ^ Williams, Paul (27 October 2011). BadfellasPenguin Books. pp. 243–. ISBN 9780141970295. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  8. Jump up to:a b c Kelly, Flach (13 March 2008). "I got rich from property not crime, claims The Monk"The Independent. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  9. ^ Paul Williams (2012). "The Monk"Gangland: The Shocking Exposé of the Criminal UnderworldThe O'Brien PressISBN 9781847175229. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  10. Jump up to:a b c Williams, Paul (20 April 2021). "European hunt for Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch as arrest warrant issued over Regency Hotel attack"Irish Independent. Retrieved 20 April 2021.
  11. ^ Reynolds, Paul (12 August 2021). "Gerard 'The Monk' Hutch arrested in Spain"RTÉ News.
  12. Jump up to:a b c d O'Riordan, Alison (29 September 2021). "Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch charged with the murder of David Byrne at the Regency Hotel in 2016"TheJournal.ie. Retrieved 29 September 2021.
  13. Jump up to:a b c d e Doyle, Peter (6 May 2022). "Ex-Sinn Féin councillor Jonathan Dowdall bids to halt his trial for Regency Hotel murder"Irish Examiner. Retrieved 9 May 2022.
  14. ^ MacNamee, Garreth (3 October 2022). "Murder trial of Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch to begin at Special Criminal Court today"TheJournal.ie. Retrieved 17 April 2023.
  15. ^ Reynolds, Paul (17 April 2023). "Gerard Hutch found not guilty of murder of David Byrne"RTÉ News.
  16. ^ Dalton, Eoghan (22 April 2023). "GSOC officer resigns over 'potential conflict of interest' after allegedly attending Gerard Hutch party"TheJournal.ie. Retrieved 22 April 2023.
  17. ^ Gallagher, Conor; Lally, Conor (21 April 2023). "Gsoc officer resigns amid allegations he was at party which Gerard Hutch attended on Monday"Irish Times. Retrieved 22 April 2023.
  18. ^ "CAB wins £2m judgement against "the Monk""RTÉ News. 14 May 1999.
  19. ^ Lally, Conor (8 December 2012). "A Crime Boss Who Changed with the Times"The Irish Times. Archived from the original on 8 August 2014. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  20. ^ Newstalk. "Request made to remove Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch from EU search results"Newstalk. Retrieved 23 May 2023.
  21. ^ "Wikipedia founder: EU's Right to be Forgotten is 'deeply immoral'"www.telegraph.co.uk. Retrieved 23 May 2023.
  22. ^ Elley, Derek (31 July 2003). "Veronica Guerin. (movie review)"Daily Variety. Archived from the original on 8 August 2014. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  23. ^ "Watch Dirty Money S1E5 Online - The CAB operation against bank robber Gerry Hutch - TV Shows - SideReel". Retrieved 17 September 2014.
  24. ^ "Monk paid up to stop CAB questioning wife - Independent.ie"Independent.ie. Retrieved 17 September 2014.
  25. Jump up to:a b Lally, Conor (9 February 2016). "Who are the Hutches? A profile of the Dublin family"The Irish Times. Retrieved 25 March 2016.
  26. ^ "Irish taxi industry website quoting Irish Times, 6th June 2001".
  27. ^ O'Brien, Carl (9 January 2004). "Taxi-drivers convicted of rape, murder to be denied licences"The Irish Times. Archived from the original on 8 August 2014. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  28. Jump up to:a b Mallon, Ian (20 April 2009). "Credit crunch forces Monk to sell luxury limo"Evening Herald. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  29. ^ "Huge, heavy and it's here... the Hummer hits Wicklow"The Irish Times. 30 November 2005. Archived from the original on 24 September 2015. Retrieved 6 August 2014.
  30. ^ "Showbiz Ireland, 28th March 2006".

 

Inside Kinahan cartel rise & bitter revenge lust – and what Christy Kinahan told gardai when he was caught red-handed

 Aoife Bannon  26 Apr 2023 

In1987Christywasslappedwitharelatively-lean six-year-jail-sentence-whic Iris SunCrimeEditorStephenBreenbelieveswascrucialtothecartel’ssuccess

In 1987, Christy Kinahan was slapped with a relatively-lean six-year jail sentence, which Irish Sun Crime Editor Stephen Breen believes was crucial to the cartel’s success.

Followinginthefootstepsofnotoriousheroinpeddler-LarryDunne-pictured above-ChristysethimselfupinFairviewinaquietapartmentblock

Following in the footsteps of notorious Dublin heroin peddler Larry Dunne (pictured above), Christy Kinahan set himself up in  Fairview in a quiet apartment block to peddler heroin in Dublinimages/ChristyKinahan-onheroincharges-cartelkingpinturnedpaleafterhewascaughtred-handed-beforecroaking-I’m as sick as a parrot-.jpg

Christy Kinahan on heroin charges:

Christy Kinahan cartel kingpin turned pale after he was caught red handed before croaking "I’m as sick as a parrot"

In April 2022, the Kinahan trio were officially targeted by the United States Department of the Treasury who have put up a $5million bounty for any information leading to their arrests. And while the brazen Kinahans have managed to stay on the run, holed up out of reach of US law enforcement overseas, Christy’s early forays into criminality were a far less sophisticated operation.

FormerGardaAssistantCommissionerMichaelO’Sullivan-recallshowChristybeganpreyingonDublin’svulnerabledrugusers.jpg

Former Garda Assistant Commissioner Michael O’Sullivan recalls how Christy Kinahan began preying on Dublin’s vulnerable drug users

Top ex-cop Mr O’Sullivan explained: “It was the most heroin I’d seen to that date and sitting nearby was Chris Kinahan.

ChristyKinahan-retiredGardaresponsiblefornailingChristyKinahanonheroinchargestoldhowcartelkingpinturnedpaleafterhewascaughtred-handedChristy Kinahan

The retired Garda responsible for nailing Christy Kinahan on heroin charges has told how Christy Kinahan the cartel kingpin turned pale after he was caught red-handed

"From my recollection, when he looked at me, he went pale. And he said, ‘I’m as sick as a parrot.’” While he initially admitted to being responsible for the drugs haul, Christy changed his tune when he was brought before the courts and blamed an Algerian accomplice, whilst also claiming he himself was struggling with addiction. In 1987, he was slapped with a relatively-lean six-year jail sentence, which Irish Sun Crime Editor Stephen Breen believes was crucial to the cartel’s success. He said: “If he had been given a longer custodial sentence, it would have kept him off the streets a lot longer and therefore would have curtailed his further advancement into the world of drugs.

ChristyKinahan-InApril2022theKinahantriowereofficiallytargetedbytheUnitedStatesDepartmentoftheTreasury

In April 2022, the Kinahan trio were officially targeted by the United States Department of the Treasury

PatrickHutch, brotherofGaryHutchchargedwiththe murderofDavid Byrne

Patrick Hutch, brother of Gary Hutch was charged with the murder of David Byrne

Manholdinga gundressedasawomanrunning fromRegency Hotel5thFebruary 2016afte theexecutionofKinahanGangMember DavidBurn

Man holding a gun dressed as a woman running from Regency Hotel 5th February 2016 after the execution of Kinahan Gang Member David Burn

ManknownasFlatCaprunmingfromRegencyHotel 5th February2016afterexecutionofKinahanGangMemberDavidBurn

Man known as Flat Cap running from Regency Hotel 5th February 2016 after execution of Kinahan Gang Member David Burn

A Man known as Flat Cap, running from Regency Hotel on 5thFeb 2016 after execution of Kinahan Gang Member David Burn

‘FlatCap’KevinMurray-wasfacing chargesovertheshootingdeadofKinahangangsterDavidByrne-islaidtorestas hundredsturnoutforfuneral

‘Flat Cap’ Kevin Murray was facing charges over the shooting dead of Kinahan gangster David Byrne is laid to rest as hundreds turn out for funeral.

Kevin-FlatCap-Murray-hadbeensufferingfrom-motor-neuron-disease-beforehedied.jpg

Kevin Flat Cap Murray had been suffering from motor neuron disease before he died

DavidByrne- Patrick Hutch-chargedwit themurderofDavidByrne

David Byrne Kinahan Gang Member David Burn- Patrick Hutch-charged with the murder of David Byrne

The Hutch–Kinahan feud is a major ongoing feud between two criminal organisations in the Republic of Ireland that has resulted in the deaths of eighteen people, the majority of which have been perpetrated by the Kinahan family. The Hutch gang, led by Gerry Hutch, and the Kinahan Family, led by Daniel Kinahan, are the main participants. The feud has taken the form of a large number of attacks, mostly shootings, on people associated with the Hutch and Kinahan gangs (though some have been cases of mistaken identity). Most attacks have been in Dublin, a few elsewhere in Ireland, and some in Spain, including the initial murder of Gary Hutch which sparked off the feud. There was a shooting in 2014 however it is generally considered that the feud began in 2015, when Gary Hutch was murdered in Marbella, Spain and escalated after the February 2016 Dublin hotel attack. In 2016, just after the Regency Hotel attack, a Special Crime Task Force was created within the national Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau (DOCB) to combat crime gangs, especially the Kinahan and Hutch gangs. Manned by at least 10 gardaí and three sergeants the task force was scheduled to close in 2021, however despite at least 18 people being killed in the feud, their success in preventing 50 other murder attempts means it will continue operating. As of June 2018, Gardaí have seized 456 firearms, €2.2 million in cash, and €64 million worth of drugs in their efforts to tackle the feud.  Commentators have noted that the feud highlights the difficulty An Garda Síochána have with policing Irish gangs with transnational structures.  2014 - Shooting of Jamie Moore - August On 4 August 2014, ex-boxer Jamie Moore was training Matthew Macklin at the Macklin's Gym Marbella gym in Marbella, Spain which Macklin had set up with Daniel Kinahan. Moore was shot twice in the leg, in a case of mistaken identity. Sources differ on whether the intended victim was Gary Hutch  or Daniel Kinahan. Moore recovered from the shooting  2015 - Murder of Gary Hutch - September  The murder of Gary Hutch at approximately 11:30 a.m. on 24 September 2015 initiated the ongoing feud. Gary Hutch, who was 34 years old at the time of his death, was shot dead at an apartment complex in the Miraflores neighborhood of Marbella, Spain. Originally from Champions Avenue in Dublin's city centre, Gary was the nephew of Gerry "the Monk" Hutch, the leader of the Hutch crime syndicate. At the time of his death, Gary was a "well-known" criminal in Dublin, who had previously been convicted of armed robbery. After his release from prison he moved to Spain, where had lived for the eight years prior to his death Gary, unarmed at the time of his killing, is reported have pleaded for his life before being shot by his killer. Gary Hutch had been working closely with Daniel Kinahan for some time before his death. By 2014, however, he was suspected as being an informant for the Spanish police, though this would posthumously be discovered to have been a false allegation. He also tried to shoot a senior Kinahan gang member.  Allegedly, Gerry Hutch had organised with Daniel Kinahan for a close associate of Gerry's to be shot in a "punishment shooting", as compensation for Gary's supposed role as an informant. Patrick Hutch, Gary's brother, is alleged to have voluntarily been shot in the leg by Daniel Kinahan in an attempt to save his brother's life. €200,000 was also paid to the Kinahan family by Gary Hutch, in exchange for his life. Both deals, however, were reneged upon, and Gary was killed. 

  • In 2018, Dubliner James Quinn, a former boxer with a criminal record, was convicted of being involved in the murder by being a lookout and helping the killer to reach and flee the scene. He was also found guilty of a second charge of illegal weapons possession.
  • The state prosecutor called on the judge to jail Quinn for a total of 28 years - 25 for the murder and 3 for the weapons possession charges. A life sentence was ruled out because jurors rejected the prosecution's claims that Quinn was a member of a criminal organisation despite the prosecution saying the killing was part of the Kinahan-Hutch feud. The jury also found that it had not been proven that Quinn had been paid for the murder.
The full story of Gerry Hutch's arrest as footage shows Monk lifted while posing as Croatian tourist, Spanish cops described The Monk as “one of the most dangerous criminals sought by Ireland”., 
, ByJohn HandOwen Conlon, 0 18 UG 2021
 
The full story of Gerry Hutch's arrest as footage shows Monk lifted while posing as Croatian tourist - Dublin Live
 
FugitiveGerryThe MonkHutchHideoutApartmentInSpain.
 
Fugitive Gerry The  Monk Hutch Hideout Apartment In Spain
 

Spanish cops swooped on Gerry “The Monk” Hutch as he sat ordering food in a pizzeria posing as a Croatian tourist.

The Guardia Civil yesterday released footage of the 58-year-old’s arrest in Fuengirola on the Costa del Sol.

They described The Monk as “one of the most dangerous criminals sought by Ireland”.

It ended nearly five months of the crime lord evading cops after he fled from under their noses when news of the European Arrest Warrant issued for him was leaked in April.

Hutch is wanted by gardai over the murder of David Byrne at the Regency Hotel on February 5, 2016, an attack authorities believe he masterminded.

The video of “Operacion Hutch” saw officers approach the fallen mob boss – wearing a green T-shirt, dark shorts, open-toe sandals and a black face mask around his chin – as he held a menu just before he was to order in a well-known restaurant.

One cop in plain clothes, wearing a red T-shirt, calmly approaches him and identifies himself with his ID while two others approach Hutch from behind, placing their hands on his back and then cuffing him.

The female associate he was having dinner with walks off as The Monk is brought to the bathroom.

There, he is searched before being sat down on the toilet.

Cops then look inside the bum bag around his waist and pull out an ID card and a passport.

A garda present examined the Croatian documents, which the investigators established as fake.

The footage then shows Hutch – held by two Spanish cops and surrounded by three others and the garda – being led through the restaurant and into a Hyundai i30 car before being whisked away into custody.

In a statement issued by the Guardia Civil, they said they had detained “one of the most dangerous criminals sought by Ireland.”

A spokesman said: “The Civil Guard has arrested in the province of Malaga the Irish citizen GH, known in the criminal world as The Monk, a native of Dublin, 58-years-old and claimed by the Irish authorities where he is accused of murder.

The investigations to locate and arrest this person began when the Civil Guard, through the Garda Siochana, learned that the Irish Judicial Authorities had accused him of murder in that country, activating a European Order of Detention and Delivery.”

Armed with that info, the Fugitives from Justice Team of the Civil Guard’s Central Operational Unit began to carry out surveillance.

We understand they went to Lanzarote, where Hutch has a holiday home, but discovered he had gone to Malaga.

He was due to return to the Canary Island in April, only to vanish once news of the arrest warrant for him leaked and they lost him.

Their next steps saw the investigators focus on the Costa del Sol and agents established that he was living there but had a “logistics network” to provide Hutch with whatever he needed “so as not to have to leave [his] hiding place”.

As revealed by the Irish Mirror yesterday, over a period of some weeks, agents noticed these people in this network separately visited a particular apartment building at No 2, Constitution Square in Fuengirola.

A unit was detailed to carry out surveillance on the building and officers watched as a known female associate of The Monk turned up.

Further inquiries also revealed the household bills for one apartment at that address were being paid for in cash at banks and post offices.

Under what the Spanish describe as “discreet surveillance” on the property, The Monk emerged last Thursday.

OutsideTheLimoncelloRistoranteFuengirolaWhereGerryHutchWasArrested

Outside The Limoncello Ristorante Fuengirola Where Gerry hutch Was Arrested in Spain

He was “walking through the busy streets of the centre of the city” and was “very focused on his safety, making numerous stops and changes in speed” the spokesman explained.

At around 7pm, The Monk emerges – unbeknownst that his every move is being tracked – and heads into a restaurant to meet a female associate when officers pounce.

The following day, Spanish cops, with the help of gardai, obtained a warrant to search the flat he was living in.

The Guardia Civil told how the Hutch gang’s clashes with the Kinahan cartel kicked off when they had The Monk’s nephew Gary killed in Mijas in 2015.

The spokesman added: “The detainee, the Irish authorities consider him responsible for the events that occurred at the Regency Hotel in Dublin in 2016, where men from his organisation, disguised as policemen, murdered a member of the rival clan using weapons of war during the time of the weigh-in for a boxing match, in a clear act of revenge.

“The investigations have been carried out by the Fugitives from Justice Team, in collaboration with the Garda Siochana and Europol, as well as with the Rapid Action Group of the Civil Guard at the time of the arrest and with different units of the Malaga Civil Guard Command.”

Hutch appeared in court in Madrid on Saturday and was remanded in custody.

When he is before a judge again, which could be as early as this week, he is expected to reveal if he will be accepting or contesting the European Arrest Warrant.

Gardai believe Hutch will contest and it could take up to six months to get him back to Ireland if he loses that fight. In that case, he will be brought straight to the Special Criminal Court and charged.

For the latest news and breaking news visit dublinlive.ie/news.

Get all the big headlines, pictures, analysis, opinion and video on the stories that matter to you.

Follow us on Twitter @DublinLive - the official Dublin Live Twitter account - real news in real time.

We're also on Facebook/dublinlive - your must-see news, features, videos and pictures throughout the day from the capital.

REGENCY SUSPECT BURIED 

‘Flat Cap’ Kevin Murray who was facing charges over the shooting dead of Kinahan gangster David Byrne is laid to rest as hundreds turnout for funeral

Dissident hitman Kevin ‘Flat Cap’ Murray’s last wish was granted when he was buried this morning Jason Johnson 

Mournerswalkbehindthecoffin‘FlatCap’ KevinMurray-Strabane

Mourners walk behind the coffin‘ of Flat Cap’ Kevin Murray - Strabane

DISSIDENT hitman Kevin ‘Flat Cap’ Murray’s last wish was granted when he was buried this morning with no paramilitary trappings - but for a wreath spelling out RAAD.

The lifelong republican, who had links to a range of terror groups, was laid to rest after a service in his home town of Strabane, Co Tyrone.

He died with his daughter at his side on Wednesday night, following a battle with an aggressive form of motor neurone disease.

He had told loved ones he wanted no shots fired over his coffin, which was not even draped with a tricolour.

RAAD is thought to stand for Republican Action Against Drugs.

It's based in the Derry and Strabane area, surfaced in 2008.

It was behind around 40 shootings and bomb attacks, claiming it was seeking to stamp out the menace of drug use. Its members were often former IRA and INLA volunteers.

It announced in 2012 that it was merging with the Real IRA.

Kevin 'Flat Cap' Murray had been suffering from motor neuron disease before he died

Murray, who had fallen out with local dissidents, had been a key suspect in a gangland killing last year at a northside Dublin hotel after being hired by the local Hutch mob. This morning his son Shane, daughter Navinne and an ex-partner escorted his coffin from his Townsend Street home the short distance to the Church of the Immaculate Conception where 300 mourners had gathered.A group of men, all in white shirts and black ties, helped bring him inside. Parish Priest Declan Boland said the 47-year-old keen Celtic fan had been baptised and confirmed at the same church before becoming “caught up in the social and political upheaval”.

He told mourners: “During our lives we make many decisions, some good, some bad.“ The decisions we make will always have consequences, that is why we have to choose wisely, prudently.” Mr Murray’s niece Cody, 22, said he had lived six months longer than expected after getting the diagnosis last year. “The only way I can describe him is as a fighter. “Kevin fought hard his whole life. First as a boxer in his youth, then later, throughout his life, for his country, for what he believed in and what he thought was right. “He wasn't afraid to stand up for his beliefs, even when at times he felt he was standing alone. “But Kevin was never alone, not with a family like ours standing behind him. Kevin faced the motor neurone disease with that same fight. “But he did not allow it to take away the essence of who he was. I don't believe anyone understood the fight Kevin had inside him until he became ill.

"He had a strong heart and a stronger mind. The way he accepted his illness and never asked why him was unbelievable.

David Byrne was shot dead at the boxing weigh-in

“His battle with MND has shown that strength is not dictated by physical capabilities but how well you can handle the fight and the people who try to knock you down.

"And nobody could handle that better than Kevin. No matter who tried to tear him or his character down, they always failed miserably.” In September last year, Murray was arrested after the shooting of Kinahan mob member David Byrne, 34, at the Regency Hotel in Dublin seven months earlier. A court in Belfast was told in December Murray, by then barely able to walk, had just a few months to live. And, despite a European Arrest Warrant being issued to get him over the Border, a judge ruled the alleged killer was too ill to stand trial. Murray, snapped with a pistol and cap as he fled the bloody scene at the weigh-in, had faced murder and firearms charges over the gangland killing. He was set to bag a huge stash of cigarettes as payment for his alleged role in the ruthless killing.

Gardai said they believed he played a “central role”.

Aweaponseizedbygardaí.jpg

" If I leave my Dublin Office I can purchase anything from Xanax, Heroin or a Glock Gun within probably  30 minutes .. now there is something  fundamentally wrong with that type of society..'... states by Dublin  Solicitor  Malachy Steenson in his interview  with Sunday World...and Virgin News  

Malachy Steenson

Malachy Steenson qualified as a solicitor in 2009. He is also qualified in the Higher Courts of England and Wales. He has worked in the provision of legal services since 2000. Malachy holds an Honours degree in Law from the University of London and also a Masters Degree in Criminology from the same University

The Bullet Proof Monk

Gerry Hutch walks free from court.

Gerry Hutch walks free through the doors of the Criminal Courts of Justice. Photo: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after not guilty verdict in Regency Hotel murder trial

Ireland's bloodiest gang wars - from the Kinahan cartel to the Drogheda feud

Ireland Deadliest Gang War Hutch v Kinahan P1

" If I leave my Dublin Office I can purchase anything from Xanax, Heroin or a Glock Gun within probably  30 minutes .. now there is something  fundamentally wrong with that type of society..'... states by Dublin  Solicitor  Malachy Steenson in his interview  with Sunday World...and Virgin News

"The fact that this open will planned brazen execution in February 2016 could happen in board daylight in a well known Dublin hotel such as the Regency Hotel, with the media at the scene, shocked the Irish Nation, and made news headlines around the world.. caused  serious questions to be asked, about  why the Irish  Garda were not on standby at the Regency Hotel, and why there was a lack of Irish  Garda Intellegence .. when well known  high profile criminal gang members  were likely to be attending this well publicised boxing  event at the Regency Hotel, sponsored by Daniel Kinahan and his  international  Kinahan Transnational Criminal Organisation  (KTCO) .."

"These Irish and International criminal gangs are a bigger threat to the security of the Irish State than all the loyalists and paramilitary groups put together...these criminal gangs are destroying  a complete Irish Generation.... as these  criminal gangs wrestle over control  of the inner city of Dublin "... "people in Ireland are asking  when will all this violence and the massive illegal  drug distribution end"... ..."we'd like to live a normal life in the city of Dublin .."..." but it appears that this  will  not happen  in the near future..".. states by Dublin  Solicitor  Malachy Steenson in his interview  with Sunday World...

Gardaí and US agents launch joint inquiry after seizure of Glock handguns

Three people arrested in Dublin following the discovery of the weapons in the post

Gardaí and US agents launch joint inquiry after seizure of Glock handguns – The Irish Times

Aweaponseizedbygardaí.jpg

A weapon seized by gardaí  Mark Hilliard Fri Oct 12 2018

Garda Commissioner Drew Harris warns Hutch mob:

'My gang is bigger than their gang' - 

Garda Commissioner Drew Harris warns Hutch mob: 'My gang is bigger than their gangIrish Mirror Online

Garda Comments To Press On Tackling Organised Crime in Ireland

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/garda-commissioner-drew-harris-warns-29803758 

The Garda Commissioner has insisted that the Hutch gang remain under investigation and warned: "My gang is bigger than their gang." Drew Harris was speaking this morning following last week's acquittal of Gerry "The Monk" Hutch of the murder of Kinahan lieutenant David Byrne at the Regency Hotel over seven years ago. The top cop is to meet with the Director of Public Prosecutions to discuss the case, but he would not be drawn on why further charges were not brought against Hutch.

The Special Criminal Court established that while The Monk could have potentially organised the Regency attack, evidence could suggest the opposite also. Ms Justice Tara Burns also told how state witness and former Sinn Fein councillor Jonathan Dowdall was unreliable and a liar. Speaking to the media ahead of addressing the Garda Representative Association in Westport, Mayo, Harris would not be drawn on why Hutch did not face extra charges other than murder.

But he did admit it was a "set back." He said: "At the same time we are on a long route march here in terms of these crime groups and bringing these individuals to justice for serious charges. "Yes there will be setbacks but the prize is that we actually break down these organised crime groups - we are determined to do that. "The prize is that we are making Ireland a hard place for organised crime groups to work. That is what I am determined to do and if I might say these gangs have some notoriety, but my gang is bigger than their gang and we'll keep working away at this." He added: "The Director of Public Prosecutions is an independent office, a very professional office in the manner they conduct their duties.

"And I have to meet with the Director in respect of this matter. At the same time I want to assure people that the Hutch Organised Crime Group remains under investigation, very active investigation.

"We are still working with the international partners in respect of that criminal grouping. So our work has not finished. This is an organised crime group. They’re involved in extensive criminality. There are other offences to investigate."

He said that acquittals are part of the criminal justice forum, saying evidence is tested to the extreme.

Harris said: “We’re determined to make Ireland a hard place for organised crime groups to work and to operate, to make this in effect Ireland a hard target and we continue with that goal in mind."

On Monday, gardai confirmed they launched an investigation into a GSOC officer who is alleged to have attended a party with The Monk. It is claimed that their officer, who has now retired, attended a "welcome home" party for Hutch following his acquittal of the Regency Hotel murder of David Byrne. The officer was facing an internal investigation into the claims but resigned during the week - meaning he did not have to engage with the probe.

Harris said the probe is to establish the facts of the case and examine the potential for criminality.
He would not speculate if the now former officer had ties with the Hutch gang but he described it as "a matter of very serious and grave concern." He said: "Obviously information within GSOC is protected in the same way it is protected within An Garda Siochana by criminal law as well, so there are potential offences, but we’re examining whether offences occur in the first place."

Ireland Deadliest Gang War Hutch v Kinahan P2

Ireland Deadliest Gang War Hutch v Kinahan P2A

Gerry Hutch cuts a relaxed figure as he emerges for a stroll in Dublin and continues to enjoy freedom - Irish Mirror Online

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/gerry-hutch-cuts-relaxed-figure-29773958 

Free man Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch looked like he doesn't have a care in the world as he stepped out in Dublin - despite the fact his life is under threat. Less than a week on from the moment he walked free from court, Hutch has been spotted several times in the capital. When he took his first steps of freedom on Monday - in the wake of his not guilty Regency Trial verdict - 'The Monk' was seen sporting long hair and a beard.

He has steadfastly refused to break his silence - but has since changed his appearance dramatically, now freshly groomed and shaven. He has now been spotted in Dublin, strolling the street in a baseball cap - with two pairs of sunglasses propped on his shirt.

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch may have fallen out with brother Patsy as possible Ireland exit plan emerges - Irish Mirror Online

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/crime/gerry-the-monk-hutch-fallen-29785615?int_source=nba 

Patsy Hutch walks on Cathal Brugha Street last week

Gerry “The Monk” Hutch appears to have had a falling out with his brother Patsy and the pair have not crossed paths since he walked free from court last week. A source revealed Patsy – who has survived three bids by the Kinahan cartel to murder him – has not visited his younger sibling since he was acquitted of murder on Monday.

Now clean shaven, Gerry Hutch, 60, has been spotted out and about in North Dublin in the days since his release.

Patsy, 62, was seen walking near his home in the north inner city hours after the Special Criminal Court heard there was a “reasonable possibility” he had planned the Regency Hotel attack.

However, the two brothers have not been seen together, fuelling rumours that they are not on speaking terms.

images/DanielKinahan-left-GerryHutch-right

Daniel Kinahan -left Gerry Hutch-right

GerryHutch'snephewDel Boylatest-to-defy-Kinaha-threat-strollingDublinstreets.jpg

Gerry Hutch's nephew 'Del Boy' latest to defy Kinahan threat as he's pictured strolling Dublin streets

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after not guilty verdict in Regency Hotel murder trial

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch early interview

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch Gangland Ireland

Gerry The Monk Hutch walks free after Regency murder trial - Crime World

Rise of the Irish Kinahan Cartel

Exclusive INL News information on the historical  background of the Gerry Hutch Gang and the international  Kinahan Transnational Criminal  Organisation  (KTCO).. which has built up billions in assets and cash from the distribution and sale of illegal drugs all around the world 
 
An INL News Group's Special Investigation  Team was formed  to investigate the gang war that broke out a few years ago between the Gerry Hutch organisation and the international  Kinahan Transnational Criminal  Organisation  (KTCO).. which has built up billions in assets and cash from the distribution and sale of illegal drugs all around the world which are both publicity  described and portrayed in the Irish Media  as the main Criminal Groups operating in Ireland and the UK.
INL News Group's  Special Investigation Team have  shown to be the  one of the  few media groups that have the tenacity, determination, ability and  preparedness  to research and reveal the real untold story of the historical  background of the Gerry Hutch organisation and
the international  Kinahan Transnational Criminal  Organisation  (KTCO).
As can be seen from  other INL News Group's  research exposed on the various
INL News Group's  websites which includes  www.inltv.co.ukwww.inlnews.comwww.awn.bzwww.wikipediaexposed.org, and many other researches around the world, which includes the late Michael Rupert, a former LA Drug Enforcement Police Officer, that it is clear that MI6/MI5/CIA/Mossad control most of the growing, manufacture and distribution of most of illegal drugs around the world, in partnership with various  criminal gangs, networks and  cartels. Michael Rupert in his 20 plus year  research  into who is behind  and controls most of the growing, manufacture and distribution of most of illegal drugs around the world, discovered that the amount of turnover and profits of the worldwide illegal drugs industry  exceeds that of the oil industry.
Watch this  space  for the rest of the INL News Group's Special Investigation  Team's Exclusive Investigation into  the gang war that broke out a few years ago between the Gerry Hutch organisation and the international  Kinahan Transnational Criminal  Organisation  (KTCO).

GerryTheMonkHutch-photographed-after-his-release

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch photographed after his release

Timeline of Hutch-Kinahan feud that started in Spain and has resulted in 18 murders

The Regency Hotel shooting in 2016 really ignited the feud - Eddie Hutch Snr was killed just days later

News By irishmirror. 18 APR 2023
DanielKinahan-left-GerryHutch-right
 
Daniel Kinahan (left) and Gerry Hutch (right)

  • The feud between the Kinahan cartel and Hutch mob was initially sparked by the cold-blooded hit on Gary Hutch in Spain in 2015.

    However, it was the attack at a boxing weigh-in event in Dublin’s Regency Hotel in February 2016 – which left Kinahan mobster David Byrne dead – that really ignited the gang war.

    Daniel Kinahan was believed to have been the target, but he escaped and fled to Dubai.

  • Here are the 18 murders resulting from the feud which shocked the nation:

    1. September 24, 2015: Gary Hutch, 34, is shot dead in Miraflores, southern Spain. Killed by the Kinahans, he is the first victim of the feud.

    2. December 30: Darren Kearns, 33, is shot dead in Cumiskey’s pub car park on Dublin’s Blackhorse Avenue. The Kinahans wrongly believed he was involved in an attempt on Daniel Kinahan’s life a month earlier.

    3. February 5, 2016: David Byrne, 33, is shot dead by the Hutch gang as he attends the weigh-in with Daniel Kinahan, 39, at the Regency.

    4. February 8: Eddie Hutch Snr, 58, a brother of Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch, is murdered outside his home in Dublin’s north inner city by a four-man Kinahan hit team.

    5. February 29: Vinnie Ryan, 25, is blasted to death at McKee Road, Finglas, Dublin. His murder has now been linked to the feud.

    6. March 23: Monk pal Noel Duggan, 55, is shot dead at his home in Ratoath, Meath.

    7. April 14: Innocent homeless man Martin O’Rourke is shot dead in Sheriff Street, Dublin, in a case of mistaken identity.

    8. April 25: Michael Barr, 34, shot dead at the Sunset House bar, central Dublin. The Kinahans believed he supplied Regency weapons.

    9. May 24: Gareth Hutch, 35, killed by Kinahans at Avondale House, central Dublin.

    10. July 1: Daithi Douglas, 54, shot dead in Dublin city. The cartel wrongly believed he tried to kill Daniel Kinahan.

    11. August 17: Innocent man Trevor O’Neill, 40, is gunned down in Mallorca, southern Spain. The true target is Jonathan Hutch.

    12. December 2: Kinahan hitman Glen Clarke is found shot in a car in Leixlip, Co Kildare.

    13. December 22: Monk pal Noel Kirwan, 62, shot dead at his partner’s house in Clondalkin.

    14. May 31, 2017: Michael Keogh, 37, shot dead by the Hutch gang in inner city Dublin.

    15. October 28: Hutch associate Jamie Tighe is blasted to death in Coolock, Dublin. His murder has recently been linked to the feud.

    16. December 2: Noel Kirwan’s son Kane McCormack, 24, is found in a Dunboyne field in Meath shot in the head.

    17. January 20, 2018: Derek Coakley Hutch is shot dead at the Bridgeview halting site in Dublin. Kinahans thought to be responsible.

GerryThe MonkHutch-photographed-after-hisrelease

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch photographed after his release

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch 'so confident he will be found not guilty' in Regency trial he has flights booked to Spain

‘The Monk’ believes he will walk out the doors of the Special Criminal Court a free man 

 https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/gerry-the-monk-hutch-so-29725992?int_source=mantis_rec&int_medium=web&int_campaign=more_like_this

 images/Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch is expected to almost immediately head to Spain if he is found not guilty

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch is expected to almost immediately head to Spain if he is found not guilty.

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch is expected to almost immediately head to Spain if he is found not guilty

GerryTheMonkHutch-The 60-year-old looks almost unrecognisable in this photograph taken around the time of his arrest in Spain in 2021 for the murder of Kinahan associate Davie Byrne

GerryTheMonkHutch-The 60-year-old looks almost unrecognisable in this photograph taken around the time of his arrest in Spain in 2021 for the murder of Kinahan associate Davie Byrne

D-Day has finally arrived for Gerry Hutch, who is said to be so confident he will be found not guilty - that he already has his flights booked. He’s spent over a year in custody in Dublin’s Wheatfield Prison, but on Monday ‘The Monk’ believes he will walk out the doors of the Special Criminal Court a free man.

If that happens it is likely Hutch, who remains a top target of the Kinahan cartel, will be facilitated with a swift exit out the side exit of the courts building - in the same way his nephew Patrick did in 2019.

He’s then expected to almost immediately head to Spain - free from the possibility of further arrest or the threat of the cartel.

If things don’t go his way then it’s back to his restricted landing in Wheatfield Prison, and a mandatory life sentence - which he may one day get to serve in Spain, awaits. But what exactly is in store this morning is anyone’s guess.

Covering the trial from the beginning I can tell you that there is no ‘smoking gun’ in the case against Gerard Hutch.

However that doesn’t mean the judges won't decide that there is compelling evidence to convict him of the murder of David Byrne.

In the end there are two main strands of evidence in this case - what’s said in a bugged 10 hour conversation - and the claims of State witness Jonathan Dowdall.Coupled together with the events before, at and after the shooting in the Regency Hotel, the State says there can be no doubt that The Monk was ‘one of the two’ gunmen dressed as gardai who shot and killed Byrne that day.

And in particular if Ms Justice Tara Burns, Judge Grainne Malone and Judge Sarah Berkeley find Dowdall’s claims credible, then Gerry Hutch is in real trouble.

Dowdall has supplied to the court what is termed ‘direct evidence,’ in that he is giving a first-hand account of alleged instances he had with the accused that the judges can determine to be credible or not.

By now most people know of Dowdall’s claim that he met with Hutch in Ellenfield Park in Whitehall either two or three days after the Regency shooting. The judges might decide that the questions around the exact timing of this incident are legitimate - given that Dowdall folded on the witness stand when challenged that phone evidence did not corroborate his claims.

But even that might not matter.

If the judges decide that the essence of the story, in that Dowdall claims Hutch confessed to murder to him in the days following the shooting, is true, then that spells a guilty verdict. They are likely to have forensically examined every word Dowdall said to gardai when he came forward in 2022, and in his incredible, but oftentimes meandering cross-examination on the witness stand. The judges may decide that Dowdall is not a reliable narrator when it comes to other evidence in the case - but if they believe him on the park confession, then that’s it.

Then when it comes to the tapes you have to remember that this was considered enough to charge ‘The Monk’ with murder in the first place. It was on that evidence that Hutch was quite dramatically returned to Ireland in a military jet and ushered into the Special Criminal Court late in the evening of September 27, 2021.

GerryThe MonkHutch-photographed-after-his-releaseP4a.jpg

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch photographed after his release

Gerry-Hutch

Gerry 'the Monk' Hutch reluctantly agreed to his nephew being shot by cartel boss Daniel Kinahan - Independent.ie

Attack on Derek Hutch - October On 9 October 2015, two weeks after Gary Hutch was murdered, his younger brother Derek "Del Boy" Hutch was stabbed while serving a sentence for murder in Mountjoy prison. A €10,000 bounty had been put on him by Christy Kinahan. He survived the attack. Hutch–Kinahan feud - Wikipedia

Murder of Darren Kearns - December

On 30 December 2015, Darren Kearns, an associate of the Hutches, was shot dead in front of his wife shortly after he left the Phoenix Chinese restaurant on Blackhorse Avenue  He had convictions for drug dealing and spent time in prison. It is thought that Kearns and another gang member are responsible for a botched attempt on the lives of Kinahan gang members.

  • No-one has been charged with the murder as of October 2021.

2016

2016 was the bloodiest year of the feud, with ten people being killed that year, six of whom were killed in the first six months of the year. Of the dead, six were associated with the Hutch gang, one with the Kinahans, and two were innocent men who were killed in cases of mistaken identity.

Regency Hotel attack, February

On 5 February 2016, a WBO boxing match for the European Lightweight title between Jamie Kavanagh and Antonio João Bento was to take place at the Regency Hotel in Whitehall, Dublin. At the weigh-in, there was an organised armed attack; the match was cancelled after the shooting.[26] There were at least four attackers wearing masks, army style-helmets and flak jackets; two of whom were disguised as members of the Garda Emergency Response Unit and armed with AK-47s. An associate of the Kinahan cartel, David Byrne, was shot dead; security sources said that the gang had intended to kill others. Two men were injured and taken to the Mater Private Hospital and Beaumont Hospital. It is believed that Daniel Kinahan, the son of Christy Kinahan, was the intended target, but he had left early. After the attack, security camera recordings suggested that six people had been involved, including a man disguised as a woman. The attackers escaped in a Ford Transit van which was later found burnt-out.

  • On 18 May 2016, Patrick Hutch, the brother of Gary Hutch, was charged at the Criminal Courts of Justice with the murder of David Byrne. His trial for murder and possession of firearms was later set for January 2018 at the non-jury Special Criminal Court; he was denied bail.
  • The trial of Patrick Hutch at the Criminal Courts of Justice for the murder of David Byrne collapsed on 20 February 2019, after the suicide of lead investigator, Detective Superintendent Colm Fox. An investigation into the circumstances surrounding the death of the Superintendent was launched by the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission.
  • In October 2020 a 26 year old Hutch gang member was arrested with a Coolock criminal when Garda detectives halted an alleged drugs handover in which over three kilos of cannabis were seized. The Kinahan cartel reportedly believe he was involved in the Regency Hotel attack.
  • In August 2021 Gerry Hutch was arrested in Spain on a European Arrest Warrant in connection with the shooting. At a trial in Ireland in March/April 2023, Gerry Hutch was acquitted, being found not guilty of the murder. Paul Murphy and Jason Bonney were found guilty of facilitating the murder of Byrne.

Murder of Eddie Hutch Snr - February

Three days after the Regency attack, Eddie Hutch Snr was killed at his home on 8 February 2016. He was an uncle of Gary Hutch. The motive for his death is suspected to be revenge for the death of David Byrne.

  • The investigation into the murder is still ongoing as of 2022.

Murder of Vincent Ryan - February

On 29 February, Vincent Ryan was shot dead while sitting in his car outside his partner's home in Finglas on 29 February 2016.[43] A brother of Real IRA leader Alan Ryan, Vincent was murdered by members of the Kinahan gang, though sources differ on whether or not this was related to the Hutch-Kinahan conflict.

  • Two men, Jeffrey Morrow and Paul O'Beirne, who pleaded guilty to assisting a criminal organisation in the murder. were sentenced to 11 and 9 years for the killing of Ryan,

Murder of Noel Duggan - March

On 23 March, Noel "Kingsize" Duggan, a friend of Gerry Hutch, was shot dead while sitting in his car outside his home in RatoathCounty Meath on 23 March 2016.

  • The investigation is ongoing as of 2023.

Murder of Martin O'Rourke - April

Martin O'Rourke was shot dead on 14 April on Lower Sheriff Street, Dublin in a case of mistaken identity. He had no known criminal connections.

  • Gardaí believe Glen Clarke was responsible for the shooting. Clarke was found dead in a stolen car in Ireland on 2 December 2016, shot through the head.

Murder of Michael Barr - April

Michael Barr was shot dead on 25 April 2016, in the Sunset House in Summerhill, Dublin. The Garda Síochána suspect he was killed by the Kinahan gang because of involvement in the Regency Hotel attack. He had dissident republican links and is understood to have provided the weaponry involved in the attack. The dissident republicans broke off ties with the Hutch gang after Barr's murder.

  • Eamonn Cumberton was sentenced to life in prison for the killing of Barr. 

Murder of Gareth Hutch - May

On 24 May, Gareth Hutch was fatally shot by two attackers in the carpark of the Avondale House flats complex where he lived.[23] He was a minor figure in the criminal world.

  • In November 2018 the Special Criminal Court found Johnathan Keogh, his sister Regina Keogh and Thomas Fox guilty of the murder. All three were sentenced to life imprisonment.

Murder of David Douglas - July - David Douglas was fatally shot outside a shop he ran with his wife in Bridgefoot Street, Dublin 8, on 1 July. He had survived being shot the previous November.

  • Lee Canavan was found guilt of the Douglas murder in 2021.

Murder of Trevor O'Neill - August 0 Trevor O'Neill, a Dublin City Council worker from Drimnagh was killed in a case of mistaken identity in Costa de la Calma, near Magaluf, on 17 August 2016 He was shot five times in front of his family.[Gardaí believe that he was mistaken for a member of the Hutch family by the Kinahan gang.

  • Glen Clarke, believed to be O'Neill's killer was found dead in a stolen car in Ireland on 2 December 2016, shot through the head.

Murder of Noel Kirwan - December

Noel "Duck Egg" Kirwan, a close associate of Gerry Hutch, was shot dead in front of his partner outside his house in Ronanstown in west Dublin on 22 December 2016. It is believed he was killed simply because of his association with Hutch, as he was photographed talking to him at Eddie Hutch's funeral in February 2016.

On 18 June, two men in their thirties were arrested by armed members of the Garda Emergency Response Unit and Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau on the Naas Dual carriageway. A Glock 9mm semi-automatic handgun was found in one man's car. Both were linked to the Kinahan gang; one was a close associate of David Byrne. Gardaí believe they were planning to shoot someone.

2017 Knife attack on Tom Fox - March

Tom Fox, on remand in Mountjoy Prison in relation to the shooting death of Gareth Hutch, was attacked on 28 March 2017 along with another inmate, suffering multiple stab wounds.

Arrest of three Kinahan associates - April An Irish man in his thirties, another aged 58, and 58-year-old Estonian man Imre Arakas were arrested by armed members of the Garda Emergency Response Unit and Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau on 4 April 2017. They were arrested in Blakestown Road in Clonsilla in a safe house owned by Kinahan associate Eric Fowler who had allegedly tipped-off Gardaí, resulting in his death in December 2018. It is believed the Estonian may be a hired killer, brought into the country by the Kinahan gang to continue the feud. Drugs and a list of Hutch associates were found. Only Mr Arakas was charged.

Shooting of James Gateley - May James 'Mago' Gateley, a 29-year-old long-term friend of Gary Hutch, had been hiding out in Belfast and Newry having fled his home in Dublin's north inner city. On 10 May 2017, he was shot fives times by a lone gunman in his car at the Topaz petrol station on the Clonshaugh Road in North Dublin. It is believed a bullet-proof vest he was wearing saved his life as four shots went into it, but he was also shot in the jaw, causing serious injuries. Gately was in a red Mondeo and the shooter was in a black Lexus which pulled alongside the Mondeo before Gately was shot.  It was the second attempt on Gateley's life in six months.

  • In July 2020 two men were charged at the Special Criminal Court with involvement with the attempted murder of James Gately. They were ordered to both reappear at the court on 8 July.
  • On 8 July 2020 one of the men was granted bail despite Garda objections.
  • On 5 January 2021 Caolan Smyth from Donore, County Meath was convicted of attempting to murder James Gately.Gary McAreavey of CastlebellinghamCounty Louth was convicted of acting to impede an apprehension or prosecution by purchasing petrol and assisting in the burning out of the car used in the attempted murder at Newrath, Dromiskin, Co. Louth. Sentencing is due on 25 January 2021.
  • In July 2021 Peadar Keating of Rowlagh Green, Clondalkin pleaded guilty in the Special Criminal Court to directing the activities of a criminal gang between December 2016 and April 2017.  He admitted gathering information on James Gately and following him as well as involving Estonian hitman Imre Arakas to kill Gately. Gately has ten previous convictions, including one in Spain for brawling.[73] Keating was sentenced to 11 years imprisonment in September 2021.

Murder of Michael Keogh - May

Michael Keogh, whose brother, Jonathan Keogh and sister, Regina were convicted in 2018 of the murder of Gareth Hutch on 24 May 2016, had Kinahan links. He was shot dead on 31 May 2017. Keogh was in his car in the underground car park of the apartment complex where he lived in Dorset Street in north inner city Dublin.

He had previous convictions for assaulting Gardaí and for firearms offences. He was before the courts in 2016 in relation to a firearms charge. He was also a known associate of Jason Molyneux and other Hutch gang members. It is believed the Kinahan cartel killed him because of this. However, he had links with numerous different criminals and Gardaí could not rule out that he was killed by another criminal gang or that he was set up to be killed by Molyneux.

  • Insufficient evidence had been found by 2021 to link the Hutch group to the murder.

Attempted murder of Gary Hanley - November

An attempt to murder Gary Hanley was thwarted by Garda surveillance of the likely perpetrators after tracking devices were found on Gary Hanley's car.

  • Alan Wilson, who had previously been tried for murder, committed in 2008 and for attacking a man with a meat cleaver during a burglary in 2009 although found not guilty of both. Luke Wilson, who had a Beretta pistol and was a nephew of Alan and Joseph Kelly who had numerous previous convictions including previous firearms and explosive convictions. Alan Wilson pleaded guilty and was jailed for 6 years, Luke, also pleaded guilty, received 10 and Kelly 11 years.[79] Others were also convicted.

Murder of Kane McCormack - December 24 year-old Kane McCormack was shot in the head on 1 December 2017. His body was found in Walterstown, Co. Meath between Leixlip and Dunboyne. He was last seen alive at 5pm the previous day after telling his partner he was going to meet someone. When he failed to return, his partner became concerned for his safety and contacted the Gardaí. His car was later found at an Aldi supermarket in Clonee.

Gardaí believe he parked his car at the Aldi in Clonee and then got into a black saloon-type car. Gardaí in Finglas later received a call that a black Audi was on fire just off the M50 at Meakstown Cottages at about 6pm.

Kane McCormack was a son of Noel Kirwan, who was had been shot about a year before as part of the feud between the Kinahans and Hutches. One line of inquiry is that the Kinahan gang believed he posed a threat to them because he wanted revenge for his fathers' death. He had been officially warned by the Gardaí that his life was in danger. McCormack had been caught with 50 rounds of .32 ammunition in November 2017. It was suspected the ammunition was connected with dissident Republican extortion rackets. Gardaí believe he had enemies other than the Kinehan gang

  • A man was arrested on suspicion of McCormack's murder on 17 December 2018 but was released without charge. On 6 March 2019, another man was arrested in Mountjoy Prison in connection with the murder but he too was released without charge.

2018 Murder of Derek Coakley-Hutch - January

At about 3pm on 20 January 2018, Derek Coakley-Hutch was shot while he sat in a car in the Bridgeview halting site beside Cloverhill Prison. He had gone to the prison earlier in the day to visit his brother Nathan, then returned to the area with two other men in a car. They were there to throw drugs over the prison wall. The two men got out of the car and went to part of the halting site where horses were kept in a pen. On hearing shots, they ran back to the car, which had moved a short distance. They tried to resuscitate Coakley-Hutch, but he died at the scene., having been shot in the head a number of times. He had been warned that his life was in danger.

Gardaí believe the killers escaped in a black Volkswagen Golf that was set on fire at nearby Crag Avenue before transferring to a black Toyota Avensis which was found burned out at Snowdrop Walk, Darndale.

Derek Coakley-Hutch had a criminal record, having previously pleading guilty to possession of an imitation firearm during the robbery of a Spar in Styles Road, Clontarf on 11 June 2015. He had carried the coffin of his uncle, Eddie Hutch, who had been shot as part of the feud.He was also a nephew of Gerry Hutch.

  • Nobody has been charged as of July 2022, despite 450 lines of enquiry.

National Boxing Stadium shooting - January

A member of the Hutch family was due to compete in a tournament on 26 January 2018. It began at the National Boxing Stadium on the South Circular road in Dublin, and there was a heavy Garda presence as a result. A car pulled up near the National Stadium at around about 9.45pm on the night of the tournament and fired at a man who is known to gardaí; he was hit in the foot as he ran towards Griffith College. The second man, who was injured in the hand, is understood to have been a student at the college who had been walking nearby. Both men, who were aged in their 40s and 20s, were taken to St James Hospital with injuries which were not life threatening.Two cars were later found burnt-out in north Dublin.

Murder of Jason Molyneux - January

Jason Molyneux, a well-known Dublin criminal with 122 prior convictions, was shot dead on 30 January 2018. He was shot at the James Larkin House flats complex on the North Strand close to where he lived, and had just returned from the wake of his friend Derek Coakley-Hutch who had been shot dead 10 days earlier. The two-man hit team immediately drove from North Strand to the nearby East-Link Toll Bridge and abandoned their Renault Kango van. They returned two hours later and attempted to set fire to it.

Attempted murder of Patsy Hutch - March

Three men were arrested in a van in the car park of the Belmont apartments in Gardiner Street at 8am on 10 March 2018.They were armed with a sub-machine gun, an automatic pistol and a revolver. Another man was arrested later in the day and further searches were conducted in several locations in Dublin. These searches yielded a machine gun and another firearm, a silencer and a quantity of ammunition.

Gardaí believed that the men were intending to attack Patsy Hutch, brother of Gerry Hutch. Patsy's son Gary had been shot dead in Spain by the Kinahans in Spain in 2015. Patsy himself has no connections to crime, but he has survived at least three attempts on his life and had been warned repeatedly by the Gardaí that his life was in danger. Despite the threats on his life he has refused to move from his home.

Gardaí believed that the men intended to create a disturbance that would draw Patsy out of his home and then attack him.

Late on the night of 27 March 2018 three walls in the north inner city of Dublin near Patsy Hutch's home were daubed with the graffiti "Patsy dies feud ends". Gardaí believe the graffiti was to draw Patsy out of his house in order to shoot him.

  • In July 2019 the three man hit squad, Gary Thompson, his brother Glen Thompson, were each jailed for 12 years and six months. Afghan war veteran Robert Browne was sentenced to 11 years and six months in prison.
  • In June 2020, Michael Burns, Stephen Curtis and Ciarán O'Driscoll were jailed for a total of nineteen years for their parts in a plot to murder Patrick "Patsy" Hutch. Burns was sentenced to nine years in prison while the other two were sentenced to five years each. The execution was to be carried out for the Kinahan gang which is organised in a hierarchical structure with cells and subcells.
  • Burns had received instructions on an encrypted phone from someone referred to as Suspect Number 1 and the evidence definitely involved in the preparation of the murder attempt. Burns passed on instructions developed by others and was not at the top of the hierarchy. Burns was also a supervisor in the plot who organised cars and phones.
  • Curtis had acted in a more limited role that was nevertheless important - he was involved in meetings and had obtained phone and SIM cards for the hit-team. He was recorded expressing reservations about Suspect Number 1 and saying he wanted to get out of the gang.
  • O'Driscoll would perform the role of watching Patsy Hutch's house until he emerged then alert the hit-team so they could shoot him. His grandmother lived on Champions Avenue and he was useful to the gang as his presence on the road would not rouse any suspicions. He took risks that were naive, such as using his own phone which assisted in his identification.He did not stand to gain in any significant way and was told that his drug debt would be cleared.
  • On 31 August 2020 Patrick Curtis, 38, of Bellman's Walk, Seville Place, Dublin 1 and Mohammed Smew, 27, of Milner's Square, Shanowen Road, Santry, Dublin 9 were jailed. Curtis was sentenced to ten years while Smew was sentenced to seven years.
  • Mr Justice Tony Hunt said both men were part of a sub-cell of the Kinahan organised crime group.Patrick Curtis was the most senior member of the subcell and he was entrusted to take orders on an encrypted phone from someone at the highest level of the gang known by the pseudonym "Lordnose". Gardaí were able to access some of the messages because Curtis could not remember all the instructions and photographed some of them on his own phone.
  • Smew had pleaded guilty to participating in the activities of a criminal organisation, namely the murder of Mr. Hutch, by providing, moving and repairing vehicles and planning or assisting to plan an attempted shooting between 1 February 2018 and 3 March 2018.
  • Smew was involved in planning and was part of the original hit team with Mark Capper, but he could not take part because he was arrested in Tallaght for looting a Centra shop during Storm Emma.
  • Their sentences were backdated to December 2019, when they were first arrested.

Arrest of two Kinahan associates - July

Two men were arrested in front of the SuperValu shop on Howth Road in Killester on 16 July 2018. They were arrested by the Garda Emergency Response Unit who found a loaded handgun in their car. The two men, aged 25 and 28, are known by Gardai to be connected to the Kinahan gang and it was suspected that they were targeting a member of the Hutch gang.

Murder of Clive Staunton - November

Clive Staunton, a street trader, was shot dead outside his home around 9:15pm on 15 November 2018. He had been selling merchandise at the Beggars Bush junction before the Ireland v Northern Ireland match at the Aviva Stadium. Normally he sold merchandise before and after matches, but he left during the game. He arrived at his home in the Glen Easton estate in Leixlip around 9:10-9:15pm. A gunman fired shots through the windscreen and drivers window - Staunton tried to escape but the gunman shot him twice in the head. The gunman fled in a silver/grey Volvo S40 which was later found burnt out in Kilbride, County Wicklow. Mr Staunton was originally from the Greek Street flats of Dublin, but had lived in Leixlip for more than 20 years.  He was a widower and was a distant relation through marriage of the Hutch family. He had minor convictions for counterfeiting, but was never involved in serious criminality. Gardai confirmed that a link to the feud was one element of the investigation.

  • Some arrests have been made, but nothing has reached court as of 2022.

Murder of Eric Fowler - December

On 22 December 2018, exactly two years after Noel Kirwan had been shot dead, 34-year-old Eric Fowler was shot in the head and killed at his home at Blakestown Cottages in Clonsilla. Two gunmen waited outside the house before running up as he was locking his car. He was shot a number of times in the head and collapsed at the side of the house despite trying to escape. A silver Volkswagen Jetta was found burnt out at Rusheeny Green in Clonee. Fowler had been formally warned by Gardaí that there was a credible threat to his life. Gardaí said there were a number of lines of inquiry, but it was possible that it was connected to the local criminal feuds in Finglas and Blanchardstown or possibly to the Kinahan-Hutch feud.

  • Nobody has been charged with the murder and the Garda have no suspect they can charge as of July 2022.

2019 Lee Boylan attempted murder - March - 24 year-old Lee Boylan was shot three times and critically injured on 6 March 2019. He was driving a van on Blakestown Road in Clonsilla close to the scene of the murder of Boylan's friend Eric Fowler over two months previously. A BMW 3 Series that was involved in the shooting was found burnt out on nearby Saddlers Drive. Boylan was an associate of the Kinahan cartel and it is unclear if they organised his shooting or if the Hutch gang were behind it. Boylan has life changing injuries.

  • The getaway driver Alan Graham, was jailed for 10 years. He had already spent 10 years in jail in 2010 when found with €750,000 worth of cocaine and €200,000 in cash.

Kinahan family and associates

The Kinahan crime family is primarily involved in the drug trade.

  • Christy Kinahan: Also known as "the Dapper Don",Kinahan, born 1958 (age 64-65), is the head of the Kinahan crime family.
  • Daniel Kinahan: Christy's eldest son, and allegedly manages the day-to-day operations of the family's criminal empire. A boxing promoter, Daniel has worked as an advisor for Tyson Fury.
  • Imre "The Butcher" Arakas: A notorious Estonian hitman, he is known for committing murders in several European countries, such as Estonia (his home country), LithuaniaSpain and Ireland, in addition to having killed dozens of members of the Russian Mafia. He is the assassin who was hired by the Kinahans to kill James "Mago" Gately (an associate of Gerry Hutch).
  • Declan "Mr Nobody" Brady: One of Daniel Kinahan's closest associates, he holds some of the most important positions within the gang: he is the main logistics man and quartermaster of the Kinahans, being primarily responsible for the gang's weapons depot and for their safety as a result.
  • Ross Browning: A native of Dublin, Ireland, he is one of the Kinahan family's top lieutenants. Considered Daniel Kinahan's right-hand man, he has been responsible for the operations of the Kinahan crime syndicate in Ireland for over two decades and as a result, he has become a priority target for the Gardaí and the CAB due to his proximity to Daniel Kinahan.
  • David Byrne † Killed February 2016 at the Regency Hotel (now the Bonnington Dublin) in Whitehall, Dublin.
  • Liam Byrne: A notorious and dangerous Dublin gangster, he is a high-ranking member of the Kinahan Family. He comes from a criminal family led by his father James Byrne (who was an associate of notorious Irish gangster Martin "The General" Cahill) and is the older brother of David Byrne, an associate of the Kinahan Family who was murdered on February 5, 2016. He is also a cousin of another member of the Kinahan family, Freddie "Fat" Thompson.
  • Douglas 'Oscar' Glynn - A footsoldier jailed for 6.5 years for involvement in the foiled plot to murder James 'Mago' Gately.
  • Leon Griffin: A footsoldier for the gang, he's a friend of Freddie Thompson and is known to be one of the most brutal and volatile criminals not only in the Kinahan family, but in all of Dublin.
  • Gerard "Hatchet" Kavanagh: He was believed to have worked as a debt collector and enforcer for the Kinahans. He was shot dead on 5 September 2014 in Elivira, Marbella. Aged forty-four at the time of his death, he had been heavily involved in the drug trade for over 20 years.
  • Thomas "Bomber" Kavanagh: One of the leaders of the Kinahan family (he is the second-in-command), he is considered by many to be Ireland's most feared mobster and is considered the main name of the Kinahan family in the UK.[130][131] He is known to be brutal and very violent, being responsible for at least 7 murders. His cousins Paul Kavanagh and Gerard "Hatchet" Kavanagh were also members of the Kinahan family (both were murdered in cold blood by "Bomber" Kavanagh).
  • Ciaran O’Driscoll: A footsoldier for the gang, he has a criminal record that ranges from possession of illegal drugs to attempted murder (he was one of those involved in the attempted murder of Patrick "Patsy" Hutch, Gerry Hutch's older brother).
  • Paul Rice: A high-ranking member of the Kinahan family, he is notoriously known for being extremely violent and because of this, he is considered a high-value target by both the Hutch family and other enemy gangs.
  • Freddie Thompson: A cousin of Liam Byrne, he was the head of the Dublin branch of the Kinahan gang from 1997 to 2008, when he had to leave Ireland over a feud he had with the INLA. Currently serving a life sentence for the murder of David "Dathi" Douglas. He is considered a key figure in the Crumlin-Drimnagh feud.

Hutch family and associates

The Hutch crime family is primarily involved in robberies.

  • Gerry Hutch: Also known as "the Monk", he earned his nickname because he does not drink alcohol, smoke, or take drugs.[141] Born in 1964 (aged 57), Gerry is the head of the Hutch crime family.
  • Gary Hutch: † He was a nephew of Gerry Hutch, and had worked for the Kinahan family, being described as once having been Daniel Kinahan's "right-hand man". His murder in September 2015 initiated the ongoing feud.
  • Eddie Hutch: † Brother of Gerry Hutch, he was shot dead on 8 February 2016.
  • Derek "Del Boy" Hutch: Brother of Gary Hutch. He is considered one of the most violent members of the Hutch family, with a long criminal record (ranging from robbery and armed robbery to murder). Del Boy Hutch changed his surname by deed poll in 2021 shortly before being released from prison.
  • Noel "Kingsize" Duggan: † A close friend of Gerry Hutch, it is known to the police that he was involved in the lucrative cigarette smuggling in Dublin. He was brutally murdered on 23 March 2016 by a team of hitmen connected to Christy Kinahan.
  • James "Mago" Gately: an associate of Gerry Hutch, he is a prime target of the Kinahans, having been targeted twice in 2017, as the Kinahans believe he played a role in the 2016 Regency Hotel attack, which it is assumed the target would be Daniel Kinahan and which culminated in the death of an associate of the Kinahan Family, David Byrne (brother of a key member of the Kinahan gang, Liam Byrne).
  • Gary Hanley: One of Gerry Hutch's most elusive associates, Gary Hanley is famously known to have escaped several attempts on his life unharmed (as a result he is considered one of the main targets of the Kinahans).
  • Jason "Buda" Molyneux: † A criminal with over 120 convictions, he was shot dead on 30 January 2018.

Gardai targeting organised crime send 40 people before court charged with 60 offences

Irish Mirror Online

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/gardai-targeting-organised-crime-send-29411457 

Officers have been undertaking targeted enforcement and preventative activity and have successfully reduced the rate of winter burglaries

BY SOPHIE COLLINS 9 MAR 2023

Organised crime group busted by Gardai in North Dublin as 40 people appear in court charged with 60 offences Gardai have sent 40 people to appear before Dublin District Courts this morning following a comprehensive policing operation conducted as part of Operation Thor in North Dublin. This operation was launched in November 2015 and was designed to tackle the anticipated increase in number of burglaries and associated criminal activities that usually occur in winter months.

Officers have been undertaking targeted enforcement and preventative activity and have successfully reduced the rate of winter burglaries, leading to a significant decline in property-related crime since its introduction in 2015. This latest leg of the operation was carried out by gardai in the Coolock and Raheny areas and specifically targeted organised crime groups and repeat offenders through coordinated crime prevention and enforcement activity based on intelligence and the latest burglary trends.

The group appearing before the courts today consists of 39 men and one woman - aged between 18 and 63.

They have been charged with a total of 60 offences including burglary and associated crime and will appear before the Criminal Courts of Justice (CCJ), Swords, and Balbriggan District Courts at 10:30 am.

Garda plan targets organised crime – The Irish Times

https://www.irishtimes.com/news/garda-plan-targets-organised-crime-1.869898

Garda Commissioner Martin Callinan and Minister for Justice Dermot Ahern have identified tackling organised crime and breaking… Steven Carroll Mon Jan 10

Garda Commissioner Martin Callinan and Minister for Justice Dermot Ahern have identified tackling organised crime and breaking gang links to subversive or terrorist organisations as a key priority for the Garda this year.

The Garda’s policing plan for 2011, published today, also says the force will continue to develop its “crisis management capability” in relation to tiger kidnappings and hostage negotiations.

The plan says An Garda Síochána will this year work to identify drug and human trafficking networks, combat low level street drug dealing and target assets that are the proceeds of crime.

“National security and the reduction of crime and fear of crime are part of our core business,” said Mr Callinan, who succeeded Fachtna Murphy at the end of last month.

Mr Callinan said the Garda would also be placing an emphasis on domestic violence, crimes of a sexual nature, the management of the risks associated with sex offenders and the support and protection of child victims.

The force last year published a domestic violence policy and policy on the investigation of sexual crime, and it established a sexual offender management and intelligence unit.

Mr Callinan said these developments would support gardaí who are “dealing with these challenging and difficult crimes and vulnerable victims”.

As well as combating organised crime, other Garda priorities for 2011 include increasing capabilities for detecting drug driving, minimising the impact of public disorder, assaults and criminal damage; and protecting vulnerable persons and groups such as children and older people in the community.

Mr Callinan said guiding principles of the plan were maximising resources by engaging in intelligence-led operations and protecting communities through high visibility patrolling.

Steven Carroll is an Assistant News Editor with The Irish Times

Gerry 'the Monk' Hutch reluctantly agreed to his nephew being shot by cartel boss DanielKinahan

Paul Williams

Gerry Hutch walks free from court.

Gerry Hutch walks free through the doors of the Criminal Courts of Justice. Photo: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin

April 22 2023 

Gerry 'the Monk' Hutch reluctantly agreed to his nephew being shot by cartel boss Daniel Kinahan as part of a bizarre deal to prevent a war erupting between the two crime clans.

The move followed a botched attempt to assassinate Kinahan in Marbella on August 4, 2014 which had been hatched by Gary Hutch and his brother Patrick, the sons of Patsy Hutch.

https://m.independent.ie/irish-news/crime/gerry-the-monk-hutch-reluctantly-agreed-to-his-nephew-being-shot-by-cartel-boss-daniel-kinahan-42444281.html

 Daniel Kinahan flees to Iran from Dubai over fear of being used as a ‘bargaining chip

https://www.msn.com/en-ie/news/world/daniel-kinahan-flees-to-iran-from-dubai-over-fear-of-being-used-as-a-bargaining-chip/ar-AA1a82KM?ocid=msedgntp&cvid=ef70a5e5efd34456926df32a91b0d676&ei=11

Story by Ken Foy and Ali Bracken 

Cartel boss Daniel Kinahan is believed to have fled Dubai and relocated to Iran as he desperately tries to avoid extradition to face justice, the Irish Independent can reveal.

As Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch enjoyed his first few days of freedom in Dublin this week, it is understood that senior members of the Kinahan cartel – including its leader – have fled Dubai for a “safe haven” within Iran.

The 45-year-old mob boss is under mounting pressure from law enforcement agencies across the globe and is understood to have become “fearful” in recent months that authorities in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) would “hand him over” to the US police or An Garda Síochána.

This is despite Kinahan allegedly handing over “huge sums” to corrupt officials within Dubai to ensure his family’s protection and freedom over the past couple of years.

Senior members of the cartel are concerned that living in the UAE is “no longer safe” as gardaí and the US authorities pressure the government there to expel Kinahan and his associates.

A source said: “Daniel and his immediate family do not want to run this risk and are believed to be gone, for now at least.

“There have been recent cases involving the authorities in the UAE agreeing to hand over criminals to other jurisdictions that seek them, such as the Americans. The Kinahans fear they could well be used as a bargaining chip.

“Their reality is Dubai is no longer considered to provide them with the protection it once did.”

It is understood the Kinahan cartel has links to terrorist groups in Iran as well as funding.

Revealed: Daniel Kinahan ‘sent weapons to Spain in botched hit’ on Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch

From stealing lemonade to murder – the crimes ‘The Monk’ was convicted of and the ones he wasn’t

Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch’s nephew Ross ‘now in complete panic’ after losing prison protection of uncle

Clean-shaven Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch spotted sporting new look on streets of Dublin today

GerryTheMonkHutch-photographed-after-hisreleaseGerry "The Monk" Hutch photographed after his release

GerryTheMonkHutch-photographed-after-hisrelease

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch photographed after his release

GerryTheMonkHutch-photographed-after-his-release

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch photographed after his release

GerryTheMonkHutch-photographed-after-his-release

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch photographed after his release

 

 Hutch Kinahan Feud - Gangland Ireland

 

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch

Gerry Hutch walks free from court.

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch

Gerry-The Monk-Hutch photographed after his release

Gerard "Gerry" Hutch is an Irish criminal. He was the prime suspect for two of the biggest armed robberies in Irish history. Known for leading a "disciplined, ascetic lifestyle" since leaving prison in 1985, he was nicknamed " The Monk " by Veronica Guerin, an investigative journalist who was assassinated in 1996.

Hutch acquitted in Regency shooting trial Frank Greaney

What now for Gerry-The Monk-Hutch and Jonathan Dowdall 

Gerry Hutch - Wikipedia

Gerard "Gerry" Hutch Early life

Born in central Dublin, his criminal career began at the age of 10.

At some point in the 1970s, Hutch joined the Bugsy Malone Gang of inner city youngsters (named for the Bugsy Malone film), which he later led, and whose crimes included "jump-overs" - jumping over bank counters, grabbing cash and running.

He was later part of a gang involved in major robberies and received many convictions between 1970 and 1983 intermittently spending time in prison.

His gang was said to have amassed an estimated IR£40 million from a series of bank robberies, jewellery heists, and fraud scams spanning almost eight years. Hutch has also been awarded money from legal actions in Irish courts. These included £8,500 won from Securicor Ireland in June 1991, £2,000 from the Sunday Tribune newspaper in a libel action and around £26,000 won in legal actions against the Irish state.

Hutch admitted to being a "convicted criminal" in a 2008 interview with The Independent, but insisted that he made his money through property deals, not crime

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after being cleared of the murder of David Byrne

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after being cleared of the murder of David Byrne

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after being cleared of the murder of David Byrne

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after being cleared of the murder of David Byrne

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after being cleared of the murder of David Byrne

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch seen leaving the court after found not guilty of murder. The boxer had been on trial for the murder of David Byrne, who was shot six times at a boxing weigh-in at Dublin's Regency Hotel in Dublin

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch on his way to court 

Gerry Hutch leaves Cloverhill Prison to hear murder trial verdict
Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch Leaving Cloverhill on the way to the CCJ
 
GSOC officer resigns amid claims he attended party with Gerry Hutch

An investigator with the Garda Ombudsman Commission has resigned amid allegations he attended the same party as Gerard 'The Monk' Hutch on the day he was cleared of murder.

It's understood the officer, who has been involved in a number of high-profile investigations into garda misconduct, told a number of people he had attended the house party with the gangland crime boss on Monday night.

Other officers in the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission (Gsoc) learned of the claims and it was reported to senior management.

A formal disciplinary process began after the chairman and two commissioners within Gsoc were informed.

It's understood he was due to be suspended, but his resignation has now been accepted.

In a statement issued at lunchtime on Saturday, the Minister for Justice Simon Harris said: "This is a serious matter which needs to be investigated. That investigation is being considered by GSOC, so it would not be appropriate for me to comment on it at this time.

"I have requested a report from the Chairperson of GSOC, which I expect to receive in the coming days.

"I will say that GSOC has a vital role in upholding confidence in policing in Ireland, and it is incredibly important that public confidence in GSOC be maintained."

Bearded and long-haired, Hutch walked free from the Special Criminal Court on Monday after being found not guilty of the murder of David Byrne at the Regency Hotel in 2016.

He was later photographed clean-shaven and with a fresh haircut in Dublin ahead of celebrations to toast his release.

It remains unclear if the Gsoc officer actually attended the Hutch party or if he merely told people he had, but such was the level of concern, senior management decided to act immediately.

The Garda Anti-Corruption Unit is already involved in an ongoing probe into potential leaks of confidential information to organised crime figures in Dublin.

The officer was previously part of a probe into the death of Detective Superintendent Colm Fox, who was originally the lead investigator in the Regency Hotel shooting.

Det Supt Fox took his own life in 2019.

The Hutch murder trial was one of the most high-profile criminal cases in the history of the state, running for 52 days.

David Byrne, a member of the Kinahan crime gang, was shot dead at the Regency Hotel after five men raided the building, which was hosting a boxing weigh-in at the time.

It was the State's case that Gerard Hutch was one of two gunmen disguised in tactical gear who shot Byrne in a "brutal and callous execution".

However, the credibility of the state's key witness, Jonathan Dowdall, was called into question by the judges when issuing the not-guilty verdict.

Dowdall had alleged that Hutch had confessed to the murder.

Over seven years on from the killing, which fuelled the vicious and bloody Hutch-Kinahan feud, no one has been convicted of the murder.

A spokesperson for Gsoc said: “Gsoc became aware in recent days of a potential conflict of interest involving a staff member. Gsoc immediately commenced an internal investigation into the matter. The officer concerned has now submitted their resignation and Gsoc's investigation is ongoing. Gsoc has no further comment at this time.”

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/courtandcrime/arid-41122288.htm
The Minister for Justice Simon Harris "has requested a report from the Chairperson of GSOC, which I expect to receive in the coming days"
 
GSOC officer resigns amid claims he attended party with Gerry Hutch
Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch walks free after he was acquitted of the murder of David Byrne at the Special Criminal Court...Picture Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after not guilty verdict in Regency Hotel murder trial

Story by TheJournal.ie team 

Gerry Hutch walks free from court after not guilty verdict in Regency Hotel murder trial (msn.com)

 

Delivering the court’s judgement on Hutch’s charge, Justice Burns delivered a scathing assessment of the evidence of former Sinn Féin councillor Jonathan Dowdall.

Dowdall (44) was due to stand trial for Byrne’s murder alongside Hutch but pleaded guilty in advance of the trial to a lesser charge of facilitating the murder.

Dowdall was being assessed for the Witness Protection Programme when he gave evidence for the State against Hutch.

Justice Burns today said that Dowdall “wasn’t transparent in court” and that the court must consider his reliability. 

“It cannot be said that Jonathon Dowdall found God, he was acting out of his own self interest,” the judge said. 

The judges also found that sections of audio from a listening device inside a vehicle as Hutch and Dowdall allegedly travelled to Northern Ireland did not give rise to inference that Hutch was present at the Regency at the time of the shooting. 

The court found that the recordings do not contain an admission that Hutch was present at the Regency, adding that in reality the recording was an interaction between criminals who are not honest with each other. 

The court said that the recordings could give inference to the idea that he organised the shooting but that this question wasn’t the case that was being tried.

At most, Justice Burns said the evidence gave rise to the possibility that he “gave the go-ahead” but the case against Hutch, she said, is not one of common design.

Even if it were one of common design, the judge said that there would be a “question mark over that also”.

All three men were in court to hear the verdicts today. 

Hutch wore a white shirt and a dark blazer and is sporting long hair and a beard. Murphy and Bonney wore hoodies and were seen chatting before the court was asked to rise.

Hutch trial: Five questions still to answer after The Monk's acquittal

GSOC officer resigns amid claims he attended party with Gerry Hutch

Fine Gael was out of the stalls on Tuesday with a press release saying that Mary Lou McDonald and Sinn Féin have further questions to answer. They are not the only ones, writes Sean Murray

Hutch trial: Five questions still to answer after The Monk's acquittal (irishexaminer.com)

Thomas "Bomber" Kavanagh Arrested By Police

In July 2020 Thomas "Bomber" Kavanagh, along with Gary Vickery and Daniel Canning pleaded guilty to drugs and money-laundering offences at Ipswich Crown Court. In March 2022 the court sentenced Kavanagh, Vickery and Canning to jail for 21 years, 20 years and 19 years six months respectively

Thomas "Bomber" Kavanagh is an Irish criminal and a senior member of the Kinahan Organised Crime Group founded by Christy Kinahan.
He was one of the first targets of the Criminal Assets Bureau

Thomas "Bomber" Kavanagh is a member of the Byrne organised crime group, a branch of the Kinahan crime organisation. Originally led by Christy Kinahan

The Crumbling Kinahan Empire

Kinahan downfall - It's over what happens now Paul William

Daniel Kinahan Irish gangs boxing obsession -Nicola Tallant

Bob Arumflips on Daniel Kinahan  Reaction to extraordinary interview Tyson  links Boxing

Garda Commissioner Drew Harris warns Hutch mob:

'My gang is bigger than their gang' - 

Irish Mirror Online

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/crime/convicted-killer-who-getaway-driver-29740719?int_source=taboola&int_medium=display&int_campaign=organic 

Convicted killer who was getaway driver in murder that sparked Limerick feud is jailed for accidentally shooting friendoffey said he was a friend of Mr Murphy's and denied any involvement.

Paul Coffey

A convicted killer who acted as a getaway driver in a murder that sparked a ten-year gangland feud in Limerick 23 years ago has been jailed for five years after "accidentally" firing a shotgun that injured his friend.

Paul Coffey, who has 100 previous convictions, pleaded guilty last March to the reckless discharge of a firearm and to possession of a firearm in circumstances suggesting he did not have it for a lawful purpose. At the Central Criminal Court today Mr Justice Paul Burns sentenced Coffey to six years in prison with the final 12 months suspended for three years in respect of the possession charge. The judge sentenced Coffey to three years for the reckless discharge offence, to run concurrently.

On his release from prison, Coffey will be required to work with the probation services and to keep the peace. The judge had set the headline sentence at nine years but reduced that having considered mitigating factors including Coffey's guilty plea. The judge also noted that at the time of the offence Coffey was homeless and using crack cocaine and heroin but is now drug-free in prison. Coffey's counsel had asked the court to suspend part of any sentence to incentivise Coffey's continued rehabilitation. Coffey's sentence will be backdated to August 2021 when he first went into custody.

 

READ MORE - Two men arrested over July 2020 shooting of Thomas McCarthy in Ballyfermot, Dublin

Coffey (46) of Lord Edward St, Limerick City, was initially charged with attempting to murder Alan Murphy at Long Pavement, Watch House Cross, Limerick on June 11, 2020.

The Director of Public Prosecutions later agreed to drop the attempted murder charge and accepted a plea of guilty to discharging a firearm, being reckless as to whether any person would be injured, at Long Pavement on June 11 2020.

Coffey also pleaded guilty to possession of a firearm in such circumstances as to give rise to a reasonable inference that he did not have it in his possession for a lawful purpose on the same occasion.

At a sentencing hearing last month Sgt Dave Barry told the court that Coffey was linked to the shooting by CCTV footage and firearms residue evidence. Following the shooting, Mr Murphy was able to drive into Limerick City where he stopped passersby who then alerted the emergency services. Mr Murphy was treated at Limerick University Hospital for superficial injuries to his abdomen.

Gardai arrested Coffey and interviewed him 17 times. In interview, Coffey said he was a friend of Mr Murphy's and denied any involvement. In his final interview gardai asked him to account for his presence at the scene of the shooting but he remained silent.

Several members of Kinahan cartel granted protective custody in prison

 

It's understood they no longer have the cash to pay for their drug debts as the Kinahan cash machine dries up

 News By John Kieran 21 APR 2023

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/kinahan-cartel-members-protective-custody-29772930?int_source=nba

Daniel Kinahan

There are currently 20 to 30 Kinahan gang members serving sentences in prison, including a number of known hitmen

A number of Kinahan cartel members have been put into protective custody in prison at their own request.

It is understood they no longer have the cash to pay for their drug debts as the Kinahan cash machine dries up

A prison source said: "These guys were getting a couple of hundred of euros a month from the Kinahan cartel to pay for their drugs behind bars. READ MORE - Timeline of Hutch-Kinahan feud that started in Spain and has resulted in 18 murders

"They have now stopped receiving any cash as the Gardai, the American Drug Enforcement Agency and the Spanish authorities turn the screw on the whole Kinahan crime organisation.

"The Kinahans are a spent force and no longer carry the power and the money that they had in this country.

"Some of these gang members have run up drug debts inside jail and haven't got the money to pay for it.

"A number have asked the prison authorities to protect them because they are worried about their safety and fear they will be attacked by other gangs if they don't pay up."

A couple of hundred prisoners across the country are normally kept in permanent protective custody at any given time if they request it.

Some stay locked up on their own while others are put in a landing with prisoners that are not a danger to them.

Prison sources say drugs continue to be smuggled into Irish jails every day despite the best efforts of the Irish Prison Service to stop it.

Drones have been used to drop drugs into Mountjoy and Wheatfield prisons in the past.

There are currently 20 to 30 Kinahan gang members serving sentences in prison, including a number of known hitmen.

The prison source added: "The Kinahan gang do not have the organisation here that they used to have.

"Since the Regency shooting and the feud with the Hutches they have taken a lot of hits to the organisation from the police and much of their whole money laundering operations both in Ireland and Spain has been seriously damaged and dismantled.

"You need cash to stay top of the tree in the Narco world and if you don't have it, you are in trouble."

esterday, it was revealed that the head of the cartel, Daniel Kinahan, has fled from their bolthole in Dubai to Iran which does not have an extradition treaty with either Ireland or the United States.

A Garda Supt along with US DEA agents have been monitoring the family in the United Arab Emirates.

It is understood that if the ring leaders of the cartel, Dad Christy, and sons Daniel and Christy Jnr are captured the Irish Government is willing to let them stand trial in America.

The US authorities have already put a $5 million dollar bounty on each of their heads.

A Government insider said: "There are serious charges against them in the USA and they should first face the music there, The punishment and the prisons are also far more severe than here."

Ireland's bloodiest gang wars - from the Kinahan cartel to the Drogheda feud

The fight for power and dominance has always been at the core of all gangland battles

News By Emma McMenamy , 22 SEP 2020

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/irelands-bloodiest-gang-wars-kinahan-22715879

images/DanielKinahan-left-GerryHutch-right

Daniel Kinahan-left GerryHutch-right

images/GerryHutch-Daniel Kinahan

Gerry Hutch and Daniel Kinahan

images/JohnHutch(left) athisbrother,-EddieHutchSnr's-funeralMay2016

John Hutch(left) at his brother-Eddie Hutch Snr's-funeral May2016

images/'Fat'FreddieThompson

'Fat' Freddie Thompson.

images/Westiegangmember-StephenSugg

Westie gang member Stephen Sugg

RobbieLawlor

Robbie Lawlor.

Ireland has seen its fair share of bloody gangland feuds over the years.

From the notorious Kinahan cartel and the Hutch gang feud to the Dundon-McCarthy criminal outfit taking on the Keane-Collopy gang in Limerick, the fight for power and dominance has always been at their core.  

THE KINAHAN CARTEL – HUTCH GANG  

Without a doubt the bloodiest feud in Irish history. The Kinahan cartel and Hutch gang feud started in September 2015 when Gary Hutch, the nephew of Gerry ‘the Monk’ Hutch, was murdered in Spain.  

He is believed to have been murdered by the Kinahan gang, of which he was once a member, for being an alleged garda informer.  

It’s understood his family had negotiated for months to spare his life and paid €200,000 to do so.   

However, the deal was reneged on and he was murdered anyway.  

In December 2015, just three months later, Gerry Hutch escapes an attempt on his life when two men in balaclavas burst into a pub in Lanzarote just minutes after he had left. 

What followed was the murder of David Byrne, 35, in February 2016 when armed men wearing imitation Garda SWAT team uniforms stormed a boxing fight weigh in and targeted a number of those in attendance.  

Just three days later, Gerry Hutch’s innocent taxi driver brother Eddie Hutch Snr, was gunned down at his flat on the North Strand in Dublin. 

And the following month Noel 'Kingsize' Duggan, a friend of ‘The Monk’ was shot dead while sitting in a car in the Old Mill housing estate in Ratoath, Co Meath.

What followed was years of tit-for-tat killings which resulted in up to 18 lives being claimed, many of them innocent bystanders.  

They included innocent dad-of-three Martin O’Rourke who was killed in a case of mistaken identity as well as Dubliner Trevor O’Neill who was gunned down as he walked with his young family during a holiday in Spain. 

THE CRUMLIN- DRIMNAGH FEUD IN DUBLIN   

The feud began in 2001 and led to at least 12 people being murdered, multiple stabbings, shootings and pipe bomb attacks.  

It kicked off when a drugs shipment of €1.5m worth of cocaine and ecstasy was seized by gardai while trying to be smuggled into Dublin.  

Members of the same gang split following the seizure and years of bloodshed ensued. 

The first victim of the feud was Declan Gavin, 21, who was stabbed to death outside an Abrakebabra fast food shop in Crumlin by a masked man in August 2001. 

His killing led to Gavin's pal Freddie Thompson going to war with his rival Brian Rattigan from Drimnagh. 

The next victim was Jospeh Rattigan, brother of gang leader Brian Rattigan, who was murdered the following July. 

In February 2004, Paul Warren, 23, was shot dead in a suspected retaliation attack for Joseph Rattigan's murder. 

In March 2005, the same gang suspected of killing Joseph Rattigan murder John Roche, 24, in Kilmainham, Dublin. 

In 2019, following an appeal, Brian Rattigan is sentenced to nine years for the manslaughter of Gavin in August 2001. 

While one time rival Freddie Thompson is currently serving a life sentence for the murder of David Douglas. 

THE DROGHEDA FEUD  

The Drogheda feud, which is thought to involve up to 80 people, is believed to have started in July 2018 when a local man was shot and wounded in Drogheda, Co Louth. He survives the attack but is left paralysed.  

The war escalated and in late 2018 when a young man was found beaten and stabbed in a bathroom. Arson attacks and petrol bombs being thrown at houses followed.  

The feud grabbed national headlines in particular when the limbs of 17-year-old Keane Mulready-Woods were discovered in a bag in Dublin. 

It’s believed he had no idea he was going to be killed after he was coaxed into a car and lured to a meeting at a nearby house. 

Gardai are now satisfied that evil hitman Robbie Lawlor attacked the teenager and watched him die. 

One bag with his limbs was dumped on a pavement in Darndale, Dublin, in January.  

The next day his head, hands and other body parts were found in a burnt-out car in Drumcondra. 

Despite extensive efforts by gardai, his torso was never found. 

A second suspect then hacked up the body with an axe and put the remains into separate bags. 

Gardai and the public were shocked by the brutality of his death.    

THE GUCCI GANG VS RIVALS IN DUBLIN                    

THE Gucci gang have been causing mayhem across Coolock, Finglas and West Dublin for the last couple of years.  

The criminal outfit members, who are mostly teenagers or men in their early 20’s, are known as The Gucci Gang because of their love for designer gear.   

They have taken over the drugs turf in these areas causing many feuds with local rival gan

They are led by a thug called Mr Flashy who is also linked to the Kinahan Organised Crime Group and is involved in a violent feud of his own in the general Finglas area. 

He is known to recruit teenagers as young as 13 to carry out his dirty work. 

THE LIMERICK FEUD – MCCARTHY-DUNDONS AND THE KEANE-COLLOPY GANG  

THE feud began in 2000 when criminals Christy Keane and his close ally Eddie Ryan fell out.  

A school yard row between their daughters is believed to have been the catalyst with Keane being approached by Ryan while sitting in a parked car outside a school waiting for one of his two children.  

Ryan produced a gun which jammed. Just two nights later there was a reprisal when Ryan was shot dead while drinking in a bar.  

As the feud between the two developed, Ryan’s family formed allegiance with the McCarthy-Dundon faction while Keane joined forces with the Collopys. 

 

The feud was centred around the Moyross and Ballinacurra Weston areas where the McCarthy/Dundon side lived. 

The opposing faction lived generally in the Saint Munchin’s Park area - also known locally as the Island Field. 

Years of violence followed including a man being stabbed 17 times and left for dead and a man being tortured and shot.  

In one dramatic episode Eddie Ryan’s sons were allegedly kidnapped as part of a supposed double cross strategy to target gang boss Kieran Keane. 

In January 2003 Eddie Junior and Kieran ‘Rashers’ Ryan were bundled into a van. 

The theory explored by gardai was that the Dundon mob had offered to shoot the brothers. It was believed Kieran Keane offered to pay €60,000 in return for the Ryan brothers’ murder. 

It was in fact a double cross and was used to lead Kieran Keane into a trap - he was subsequently murdered. 

It is believed that 20 murders happened after Eddie Ryan was shot dead at the Moose Bar in Limerick. 

In recent years, the leaders of the McCarthy-Dundon's, Wayne, Dessie and John Dundon, have been sentenced to life imprisonment for different murders, resulting from gang members and relatives of the brothers becoming supergrasses. 

The feud is believed to have claimed up to 13 lives.  

THE WESTIES IN DUBLIN VS LOCAL DRUG GANGS 

The Westies were one of the most feared gangs in Dublin during the early 2000’s and controlled the drug trade in the capital with an iron fist.  

The gang was known for its extreme violence against rival gangs and drug addicts who couldn’t pay their debts.  

The Westies ruthless crime bosses Shane Coates, 31, and 27-year-old Stephen Sugg were found buried in concrete in an industrial estate on Spain’s Costa Blanca.  

The men were executed and their bodies covered over in Catral, 15km from the popular resort of Torrevieja and 40km from Alicante.  

Those behind their brutal murders had gone to extreme lengths to conceal the bodies.  

They had dug a 6ft grave, dumped the men’s remains in the hole and covered it with concrete.  

The feared drug kingpins had been missing for two years and were last seen in January 2004 as they left their apartments at Orihuela Costa, outside Torrevieja.  

hey had told their girlfriends they would be back in an hour but were never seen alive again.  

Coates first fled Ireland following a shoot-out with undercover gardai in Virginia, Co Cavan, while Sugg left in mid-2003 after he was shot at by other drug dealers.   

Gardai in Blanchardstown had tipped off Spanish police after an intelligence tout revealed their final resting place.  

Timeline of Hutch-Kinahan feud that started in Spain and has resulted in 18 murders

The Regency Hotel shooting in 2016 really ignited the feud - Eddie Hutch Snr was killed just days later

News By irishmirror. 18 APR 2023
Daniel Kinahan (left) and Gerry Hutch (right)

  • The feud between the Kinahan cartel and Hutch mob was initially sparked by the cold-blooded hit on Gary Hutch in Spain in 2015.

    However, it was the attack at a boxing weigh-in event in Dublin’s Regency Hotel in February 2016 – which left Kinahan mobster David Byrne dead – that really ignited the gang war.

    Daniel Kinahan was believed to have been the target, but he escaped and fled to Dubai.

  • Here are the 18 murders resulting from the feud which shocked the nation:

    1. September 24, 2015: Gary Hutch, 34, is shot dead in Miraflores, southern Spain. Killed by the Kinahans, he is the first victim of the feud.

    2. December 30: Darren Kearns, 33, is shot dead in Cumiskey’s pub car park on Dublin’s Blackhorse Avenue. The Kinahans wrongly believed he was involved in an attempt on Daniel Kinahan’s life a month earlier.

    3. February 5, 2016: David Byrne, 33, is shot dead by the Hutch gang as he attends the weigh-in with Daniel Kinahan, 39, at the Regency.

    4. February 8: Eddie Hutch Snr, 58, a brother of Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch, is murdered outside his home in Dublin’s north inner city by a four-man Kinahan hit team.

    5. February 29: Vinnie Ryan, 25, is blasted to death at McKee Road, Finglas, Dublin. His murder has now been linked to the feud.

    6. March 23: Monk pal Noel Duggan, 55, is shot dead at his home in Ratoath, Meath.

    7. April 14: Innocent homeless man Martin O’Rourke is shot dead in Sheriff Street, Dublin, in a case of mistaken identity.

    8. April 25: Michael Barr, 34, shot dead at the Sunset House bar, central Dublin. The Kinahans believed he supplied Regency weapons.

    9. May 24: Gareth Hutch, 35, killed by Kinahans at Avondale House, central Dublin.

    10. July 1: Daithi Douglas, 54, shot dead in Dublin city. The cartel wrongly believed he tried to kill Daniel Kinahan.

    11. August 17: Innocent man Trevor O’Neill, 40, is gunned down in Mallorca, southern Spain. The true target is Jonathan Hutch.

    12. December 2: Kinahan hitman Glen Clarke is found shot in a car in Leixlip, Co Kildare.

    13. December 22: Monk pal Noel Kirwan, 62, shot dead at his partner’s house in Clondalkin.

    14. May 31, 2017: Michael Keogh, 37, shot dead by the Hutch gang in inner city Dublin.

    15. October 28: Hutch associate Jamie Tighe is blasted to death in Coolock, Dublin. His murder has recently been linked to the feud.

    16. December 2: Noel Kirwan’s son Kane McCormack, 24, is found in a Dunboyne field in Meath shot in the head.

    17. January 20, 2018: Derek Coakley Hutch is shot dead at the Bridgeview halting site in Dublin. Kinahans thought to be responsible.

Senior Kinahan crime gang figure Ross Browning has been ordered to pay much of the Criminal Assets Bureau’s legal costs incurred in securing declarations that more than €1 million of assets linked to him were obtained with crime proceeds.

Cab alleged Mr Browning, his partner Sinéad Mulhall and their children were living at a residence at the site which also encompasses a riding area and stables.

In February the judge declared these properties and several other assets seized in 2018 were fully or partially acquired directly or indirectly with the proceeds of crime.

He said the evidence presented by Cab established “as a matter of probability that Ross Browning has had an ongoing and significant involvement in organised crime for a significant number of years and is a senior member of the Kinahan organised crime gang”.

The Kinahan gang is “involved in the importation, and distribution of drugs and firearms in Ireland”, the judge added.

Mr Browning did not contest Cab’s application, but members of his family rejected allegations about the assets.

Mr Justice Owens rejected many of the arguments put forward by Mr Browning’s relatives about the origins of funds. Mr Browning, he ruled, was involved in acquiring the Garristown and Deanstown Road properties and lands at Rush, north Dublin.

No order was made in relation to the legal costs incurred in securing declarations and freezing orders in relation to a Garristown site cottage, called Chestnut Lodge, in which Mr Browning’s mother, Julie Conway, and her husband David O’Brien, a former garda, lived. This means each of the parties will pay their own legal fees for this element of the case.

The judge accepted Ms Conway and her husband retained an interest in the cost of refurbishing the cottage, spending up to €70,000 of their money. He directed that a quarter of the net proceeds of sale of that part of the Garristown site will go to them.

The estate of Mr Browning’s grandfather, William Conway, will be paid €59,000 from the Garristown sale. On Wednesday the judge said there would be no order concerning the legal costs between the late Mr Conway’s estate and Cab.

Cab, through its counsel Benedict Ó Floinn SC, asked the court on Wednesday for permission to take possession of the properties at Garristown and Deanstown Road properties and the Rush lands.

After hearing there was no objection regarding the Rush lands, Mr Justice Owens said these could be taken on May 16.

He wanted Cab to notify parties other than Mr Browning who are living at Garristown and Deanstown Road of its intention to take possession of them. He was not prepared to make an order permitting possession and sale of these without being satisfied the residents had been served with papers.

He adjourned this issue for a month.

Mary Lou McDonald: Jonathan Dowdall 'should not have been in Sinn Féin'

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-41121469.html

Mary Lou McDonald: Jonathan Dowdall 'should not have been in Sinn Féin' 

'Jonathan Dowdall had no business in Sinn Féin,'  Mary Lou McDonald has said. 

Former Sinn Féin councillor Jonathan Dowdall "should not have been in Sinn Féin", Mary Lou McDonald has told the Dáil.

The former councillor has been jailed for four years for facilitating the 2016 murder of David Byrne at the Regency Hotel, having previously been jailed for physically and mentally torturing a man he and his father both suspected of trying to defraud them.

Dowdall had been a Sinn Féin councillor for Dublin's Inner City North ward in the heart of Ms McDonald's constituency from 2014 to 2015 but left the party complaining of having been bullied.

 Dowdall was a key witness in the trial of Gerry The Monk Hutch which ended this week with Mr Hutch being acquitted by the non-jury Special Criminal Court of the Regency murder.

In her judgment, one of the three judges, Ms Justice Burns, said: “It cannot be said that [Dowdall] found God and decided to do what was right." She said he “acted out of his own self-interest”.

Speaking in the Dáil on Thursday during statements on organised crime, Ms McDonald reiterated that her party would not have included Dowdall had they been aware of his ties to criminality.

“For the avoidance of doubt, let me say again that Jonathan Dowdall had no business in Sinn Féin. He shouldn’t have been in our party.

“He joined in June 2013. He left in February 2015. But it was in March 2016 that his criminal activity was discovered.”

Ms McDonald, however, said that Dowdall is the only person responsible for his actions.

Mary Lou McDonald said of Jonathan Dowdall: 'He and he alone is responsible for his actions.'

Mary Lou McDonald said of Jonathan Dowdall: 'He and he alone is responsible for his actions.'

“He and he alone is responsible for his actions. He has been convicted before the courts.

If I had known for a second what he would be capable of, what he would go on to do, he wouldn’t have been near me. He wouldn’t have been near Sinn Féin, and he certainly would not have been running for public office.

However, a number of Fine Gael TDs used their speaking time to question who had convinced Dowdall to remain in Sinn Féin when he spoke of leaving in 2014. Colm Brophy said there were “many serious questions unanswered” by Ms McDonald about Dowdall, who he described as her “political protege-turned-gangland torturer”. 

However, Mr Brophy earned a rebuke from Leas-Cheann Comhairle Catherine Connolly, who said that the session was for statements and not questions.

Fergus O’Dowd and Alan Farrell also used part of their statements to ask questions about which members of Sinn Féin had spoken to Mr Dowdall about a gun attack on his uncle's home in 2011.

Justice Minister Simon Harris said he hoped that the conviction of two other men at the Special Criminal Court in connection with the 2016 Regency shooting would show the need to support the court when the legislation underpinning it is voted for in the coming months.

“I do want to send out a very strong message today: Justice always prevails. You can run. You can try to hide. But An Garda Síochána will never stop pursuing and dismantling the criminal gangs causing fear, violence, and murder across this country," he said.

Coveney: Mary Lou McDonald has 'serious questions to answer' over Dowdall vetting 

'Clear answers' also needed on whether Sinn Féin will support renewal of the Special Criminal Court
 

Gerry Hutch verdict as it happened: 'The Monk' found not guilty of murder of David Byrne as Regency trial ends - Irish Mirror Online

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/gerry-hutch-trial-verdict-live-29728884#live-event-entry-627858

'The Monk' was cleared of murder - but his co-accused Paul Murphy and Jason Bonney were both found guilty of lesser charges relating to the death of David Byrne

 

Footage of what happened on Regency showed shooter 1 was young. Shooter 2 also ran around at speed

Ms Justice Burns says Hutch, a man in 50s, does not fit the movements of the shooters.

 

Ms Justice Burns - Audio doesn’t prove he was one of the shooters

Ms Justice Burns says Hutch comments on the calmness of the hit team “in the third person” on the audio.

All matters lead to conclusion that members of Hutch family responsible she says

However “that is not the case Gerard Hutch is here to meet.”

Now moving onto the meeting with Patsy, Shane Rowan, at Malahide Industrial Estate

Court is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that Patsy was “centrally involved” in the movement of the weapons.

Court satisfied that Gerard Hutch “was in control over and had possession of guns.”

Ballistic exam of weapons seized from Shane Rowan determined they were same ones used in Regency

Court is therefore satisfied, Ms Justice Burns says, that these are the weapons.

Ms Justice Burns says Jonathan Dowdall and Gerry Hutch went to Strabane and at unknown location attended a meeting

Court satisfied purpose was to meet dissident IRA to discuss assistance to broker ceasefire with Kinahans.

Court satisfied Jonathan Dowdall was asked by Patsy to meet IRA contacts to seek their assistance to broker peace with Kinahans

And the court is satisfied that journey on February 4 and an earlier visit in January was to this end.

Dowdall and his father travelled to Strabane on February 4. Court is satisfied of this beyond all reasonable doubt

Court is satisfied beyond all reasonable doubt that Dowdalls arranged for the booking of room.

Court is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that Patrick Dowdall checked into the room

CCTV captures him arriving at the hotel and paying in cash for the room.

While Patrick is depicted alone on CCTV, Jonathan says he drove Dad there. Cell site analysis places him there.

Court is of opinion Hutch confessing would have made a "searing impression on Jonathan Dowdall's memory."

Court is of view the events of the day would have made a "lasting impression" and "one might be expected to remember" whether it was the morning or afternoon.

Ms Justice Burns says court is of the view that Dowdall is a witness in which great care has to be taken. Court is "not prepared to act on his statement alone."

Judge Burns says there is the further issue of Dowdall recognising Patrick Hutch from the SW photo

"That is just simply not possible."

Judge Burns - One would have expected "extreme panic" from Dowdall about booking the room once he learned what happened at Regency. "Yet there is none"

Court now hearing of his cross-examination and how he was challenged on the phone evidence of Sarah Skedd.

Ms Justice Burns says very specific plots were raised to harm people by Dowdall on the tape

He claimed he was stressed out at time. But Judge Burns says he "doesn't sound stressed out" on the tape.

Dowdall claims the key card was handed to Gerry Hutch on the Richmond Road, as was his account of meeting him in park in Whitehall.

Justice Burns says the park meeting is placed by Dowdall as occurring after Eddie Hutch murder. He indicated then he couldn't remember what day it was but it was after Sunday World pic emerged.

Dowdall came to court to tell a specific story but was reluctant to speak about other things

His relationship with Pearse McAuley is an example, the judge says. He was reluctant to speak about this and only accepted relationship with him when met with prison visit records.

He told a "bare faced lie" to the court about how many times he met McAuley.

Dowdall asserted he was "too terrified to tell the truth" but the available option to stay silent was not availed by him

The manner in which he told "convincing lies" is "extremely concerning to this court."

On the tape, he talked about making bombs. A real question is "who is the court actually dealing with?" "A significant question mark" hangs over Dowdall she says.

Court must assert his truthfulness about Hutch with scepticism.

Ms Justice Burns says fact Dowdall involved in such a vicious attack is disturbing

However, a person who commits such a crime can still give truthful evidence, she says.

However, in court Dowdall had accepted in court that he had "lied" before another Special Criminal Court hearing. "It is a matter the court must account for."

There is cause for concern, she says.

Ms Justice Burns now speaking about Dowdall's conviction for the torture of a man

The recording showed him torturing him. She calls the crime "shocking."

Court was asked to view the recording. They declined to do so. The issue which was in dispute was what had not been recorded.

Judge Burns says "court of view Jonathan Dowdall obtained a significant benefit by providing a statement to An Garda Siochana"

Judge Burns: "The court is in no doubt if someone was to make a life for himself in the perilous situation he's now in, it is Jonathan Dowdall."

 

Justice Burns says statement was taken from Dowdall "after a long drawn out process" ten days before trial

"It cannot be said Jonathan Dowdall found God." He was acting "out of self interest," Judge Burns said.

"As bail was consented to Dowdall was released"

The court is in "no doubt" his bail enabled gardai to speak to him on his way to the airport.

At conclusion of a meeting Dowdall was told to gather thoughts and put pen to paper. Dowdall was of opinion guards were to return to him. Guards of view he was to come back to them.

Dowdall was asked how he wanted situation to end up. He said he was willing to give evidence. He met gardai again 12 July. Further info was imparted in relation to Regency.

Letter dated August 2nd sent to gardai set out history of communications and referenced neccesity for a nolle prosequi on the murder charge if Dowdall was to give evidence.

Hutch's counsel suggested it showed lack of interest by gardai in what Dowdall had to say. "The court tends to agree."

Ms Justice Burns now speaking on Dowdall reliability

Dowdall, she says, served eight years for false imprisonment, threat to kill, assault causing harm. In June 2022 he and Hutch sought to have evidence against them dismissed. Their application failed. In December 2021 his solicitor contacted gardai about possibility of providing information.

Dowdall told Gerry Hutch he was in this with him to the "bleeding death"

Ms Justice Burns says it is well established in law that evidence of an accomplice should come with a warning in where it is in any way considered in the absence of any corroborating evidence.

There is a danger where a witness may not tell the truth in the hope of receiving benefits in witness protection programme.

Trial must bear in mind dangerous to convict off such a witness if there is not corroborating evidence

Ms Justice Burns is reading out several portions of the tape

In one it refers to Hutch flying into Dublin airport since the Regency. Dowdall makes reference to Hutch being "away" when talking about the non-stop coverage.

Dowdall is heard saying things like "even if you were here."

On part of the tape where the two discuss the six involved. Hutch was heard saying even among the six don't even know who they all are.

 

Ms Justice Burns now talking about the tapes

Audio captured a conversation. Identity of the participants is "not an issue." Northern Ireland portion was unlawfully recorded but admitted as evidence.

Court determined to exercise its discretion to admit this evidence she said.

Generally, she says, the prosecution say it establishes Hutch had authority over the weapons and that there are admissions by him on tape to involvement in Regency.

"Dowdall stated that Gerry Hutch was in a panic"

Dowdall claimed Hutch said it was "him and them at the hotel" and he said "he was not happy about shooting the young lad David Byrne."

Court is satisfied there was a dispute between the Hutches and Kinahans

Jonathan Dowdall contacted Pease McAuley "An infamous" terrorist. "It would appear he was an acquaintance of Jonathan Dowdall."

He was to meet Kevin Tyrone. This meeting did not occur but he met Shane Rowan and man referred to as 'Wee.'

Apparently, the Dowdall family making bookings for Patsy was "not unusual."

Patrick Dowdall paid in cash and got a key card. The arrangement was they were to bring it to Patsy's house. However, they then got a call to meet at Richmond. Dowdall claimed they then ended up meeting Gerry there.

"On Sunday the 7th of Feb, the Sunday World ran front page which included a photo of Kevin Murray and a man dressed in drag." Photos were pixelated and unrecognisable, Judge Burns says. Dowdall identified Patrick. Judge said that in fact was not possible.

Ms Justice Burns: "Case against Gerard Hutch that he was one of the two" gunmen

Case is he was present and an "actual shooter." This case is based off the evidence of Jonathan Dowdall.

 

The press awaits this afternoon's verdict

Members of the media outside the Special Criminal Court

Jason Bonney and Paul Murphy are now to be taken into custody

The two men, who have been on bail this entire time, are taken into custody.

 
 Family of Regency Hotel murder victim David Byrne call for Hutch-Kinahan feud to end - Irish Mirror Online

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/crime/regencyhotel-shooting-dublin-davidbyrne-patrickhutch-14029174 

Family of Regency Hotel murder victim David Byrne call for Hutch-Kinahan feud to end

By Niall O'Connor, 20 FEB 2019

'Who wants a feud? Who wants to live like this?'

The mother of the Regency Hotel murder victim David Byrne called for an end to the Hutch-Kinahan feud.

Sadie Byrne was speaking just moments after Patrick Hutch Jnr, who was accused of killing her son, walked free from court after his trial collapsed.

Mrs Byrne, whose family is currently embroiled in a Criminal Assets Bureau probe, also blasted the legal system.

Outside the Special Criminal Court on Wednesday, she said: “Who wants a feud? Who wants to live like this?

“I was never in trouble, never in an argument in me life. Who wants their child riddled? Gone to a sporting event and he doesn’t come home.”

The State dropped the charges after a lengthy delay after the death of chief investigator Det Supt Colm Fox.

He suffered a single gunshot wound in his office and a loaded Garda firearm was found nearby.

The Regency attack sparked the bloody Hutch-Kinahan feud that has claimed the lives of 18 people.

Some of whom were completely innocent and were in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Dead

Byrne was shot dead in the hotel by one of three men dressed in kit similar to that worn by the Garda Emergency Response Unit.

The court was shown CCTV and still images taken by press photographers on the day of the incident.

In these images a man wearing a blonde wig and women’s clothing carrying a handgun could be seen. The State claimed that was Patrick Hutch.

Sources have said Mr Fox had left three notes in his office which made reference to the Regency investigation.

Ballymun Garda Station and inset, Detective Superintendent Colm Fox

A source said: “It is believed Colm had made reference to mistakes in the investigation.

“It was an ambiguous reference but it is enough for a doubt to be created - they were not in a position to examine or cross-examine him on what he meant by these references.

“It is a tragic end to an incredibly detailed investigation and the only person prosecuted has walked free.”

The Byrne’s family blasted the development, shouting angrily in court. Relatives shouted: “It’s a disgrace, an absolute farce. Where is justice in this?” At one point Mrs Byrne tried to address the three judges.

Patrick Hutch leaves the Special Criminal Court after all charges were dropped against him regarding the Regency Hotel murder on Feb 5, 2019 (Image: Padraig O'Reilly)

Patrick Hutch leaves the Special Criminal Court after all charges were dropped against him regarding the Regency Hotel murder of David Byrne

Patrick Hutch Regency Hotel murder trial to resume in December as defence examines report into death of leading investigator Colm Fox

Hutch, 25, denies the murder of David Byrne at the Regency Hotel, north Dublin on February 5, 2015

Gsoc opens investigation into death of Regency Hotel investigator Colm Fox

Gsoc opens investigation into death of Regency Hotel investigator Colm Fox
The Regency trial collapsed today.

GSOC HAS ANNOUNCED it is investigating the circumstances surrounding the death of Detective Superintendent Colm Fox.

Superintendent Fox was found dead in his office at Ballymun Garda Station in February of last year.  He was a lead investigator into the Regency Hotel investigation.

Patrick Hutch today walked free from the CCJ following the trial’s collapse. 

The garda ombudsman will now investigate all circumstances surrounding the lead up to Fox’s death.

A statement reads:  “Gsoc has moved from an examination under section 91 of the 2005 Act to an investigation into the circumstances giving rise to the death of the late Det Supt Fox.

It also called for help from other agencies to assist it with its investigation.

It added: “The ability to conduct a proper oversight investigation of these events will be dependent on the cooperation given to Gsoc by the gardaí and other agencies. 

“Given the limited resources of Gsoc, considerable cooperation from all parties involved will be required for an effective investigation to take place.”

“Gsoc is conscious that behind the events which have given rise to this investigation families and friends continue to mourn the deaths loved ones.”

Fox was found dead on the evening of 10 February in his office at Ballymun garda station. His official firearm was recovered at the scene, foul play was not suspected and it was treated as a personal tragedy. The trial had been stalled at the time over the disclosure by the prosecution of emails between four gardaí.

Today, the DPP entered a nolle prosequi against Hutch today meaning the State will not be proceeding with the charges against Hutch, and he was free to walk from court.

Counsel for the DPP, Sean Gillane SC, said the the State was no longer in a position to lead evidence on a number of matters “sadly” as a result of the death of the lead investigating garda on the Regency Hotel shooting case, Detective Superintendent Colm Fox.

Mr Justice Tony Hunt, presiding in the three-judge court, said Hutch could be “discharged” in light of the State’s application. “Further comment is not necessary,” the judge said.

Members of the Byrne family stood up and called the situation “disgraceful” and a “farce”. 

Tragic lead investigator in Regency Hotel murder trial Colm Fox 'was doing work of multiple gardai'

By Niall O'Connor , 22 FEB 2019

His death led to Patrick Hutch walking free on Wednesday after the charge against him was dropped

Tragic lead investigator in Regency Hotel murder trial Colm Fox 'was doing work of multiple gardai' - Irish Mirror Online

https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/crime/tragic-lead-investigator-regency-hotel-14033815#amp-readmore-target 

The lead investigator in the Regency murder trial was performing the work of multiple senior gardai, it has emerged.

Sources have revealed the last months of Detective Superintendent Colm Fox’s life saw him performing the duties of two Superintendents and was short of detective inspectors.

He was found dead in his office in Ballymun Garda Station in Dublin on February 10, 2018.

His death led to Patrick Hutch - who was on trial accused of murdering David Byrne in the 2016 Regency Hotel shooting - walking free on Wednesday after the charge against him was dropped.

A source said: “At the time of his death Colm Fox was dealing with a huge shortfall in high ranking officers to deal with the day to day operation of detective duties.

Detective Superintendent Colm Fox (left) was the lead investigator in the Regency Hotel murder trial. Patrick Hutch (right) was accused of murdering David Byrne (inset)

David Byrne was shot dead at boxing weigh in at the Regency Hotel in Dublin on February 5, 2016.

“This was not just in the Ballymun district area - in simplest terms he has handling half of the city because another Detective super hadn’t been appointed.

“The work load was massive and it was made even worse because he was short of detective inspectors.

“He was handling all the paper work and decision making for a huge swathe of the city and there was no sign of anything being done to help him with the burden.”

At the time of his death there was a significant shortfall in high ranks.

Patrick Hutch leaves the Special Criminal Court after all charges were dropped against him regarding the Regency Hotel murder on Feb 5, 2019 (Image: Padraig O'Reilly)

Patrick Hutch leaves the Special Criminal Court after all charges were dropped against him regarding the Regency Hotel murder of David Byrne

Sources have said that there was a constant request for promotions of officers to fill those positions but they remained unfilled.

A source who knew Colm Fox said: “He was super dedicated and was one of these officers who dealt with policing as a vocation - he believed in helping people.

“He didn’t want to let the side down - the pressure on him was immense. When it gets to the inquest it will be a self inflicted injury that caused his death.

“On one side members want him to be left to rest in peace but it is important that the story around his death is explained.”

Relatives of David Byrne react outside the Special Criminal Court in Dublin after charges where dropped against Patrick Hutch (Image: PA)

Ballymun Garda Station and inset, Detective Superintendent Colm Fox

It is understood that on the night of his death he left three notes - these notes were found in his office and in post boxes of colleagues.

The notes contained references to “mistakes” in the Regency investigation but did not go into detail.

A source said: “He had expressed concerns weeks earlier that he was being set up for a fall on the Regency investigation by defence barristers.

“People dismissed this as just general bunker mentality comments but clearly he was burdened by it.”

Sadie Byrne, mother of David Byrne who was murdered at the Regency Hotel in Dublin in 2016, reacts outside the Special Criminal Court in Dublin after charges where dropped against Patrick Hutch

At Monday’s hearing in the Special Criminal Court, Sean Gillane, SC for the State,

said that they were unable to proceed with the case against Patrick Hutch in the wake of the death of Colm Fox.

Mr Gillane told the court that his team had carried out a “comprehensive analysis of evidence” as the case was adjourned as Gardai investigated the death of the officer.

He said: “Sadly with the passing of Detective Superintendent Fox we are in the situation that we are are not in a position to lead evidence on a number of aspects of the case.”

It was said during the case that two garda detectives had allegedly identified Hutch as a gunman dressed as a woman in a blonde wig from press photographs.

The case was adjourned pending the completion of the investigation into the death of Superintendent Fox.

Widow of Colm Fox sues State following detective’s death during Regency trial – The Irish Times

Garda widow speaks of stress husband was under before death

At one stage, the detective superintendent was in charge of seven murder investigations
Garda widow speaks of stress husband was under before death
Detective Superintendent Colm Fox

A widow of a senior Garda who took his life over three years ago has spoken of the stress her husband was under leading up to his death.

Edel Fox was speaking at the annual conference of the Association of Garda Superintendents (AGS) today.

Detective Superintendent Colm Fox was found dead at Ballymun Garda Station, north Dublin, in February 2018. 

A Garda revolver was found by his body.

Ms Fox is currently suing the State.

Det Supt Fox was the senior officer in the investigation into Patrick Hutch for the murder of David Byrne at the Regency Hotel in February 2016.

The prosecution of Hutch was before the Special Criminal Court at the time of his death and, following the tragedy, the DPP withdrew the prosecution, saying it could not proceed with certain evidence as a result.

While Ms Fox did not speak to the media, she gave permission for her remarks to be relayed by the association.

Supt Declan McCarthy of the Wicklow Garda division, and a member of the AGS national executive, said: “She spoke very movingly about her husband’s death and about the level of pressure and stress that the role he played within An Garda Síochána had placed upon him.” 

“She was very concerned that we, as superintendents, would also make sure to be mindful of our own welfare and matters like that."

Ms Fox told delegates that at one stage her husband was in charge of seven murder investigations in Blanchardstown, where he worked before Ballymun.

She described how she took his phone at night and hid it in the corner under a pillow so that the ring tone or flashing light would not disturb his sleep.

The president of the AGS said superintendents are expected to be continuously available to address policing and work-related issues.

Supt Seamus Nolan told the minister for justice that superintendents continuously take calls at 2am, 3am, and 4am to support frontline policing and attend fatal incidents 

HOME› TOPICS› SOCIAL & FUN› AFTER HOURS

REGENCY HOTEL SHOOTING TRIAL COLLAPSES FOLLOWING DETECTIVE SUPERINTENDENT'S SUICIDE

Regency Hotel shooting trial collapses following Detective Superintendent's suicide - Page 6 — boards.ie - Now Ye're Talkin

Regency Hotel shooting trial collapses following Detective Superintendent's suicide

«12345678 
  • paw patrolRegistered UsersPosts: 2,314 ✭✭✭ 22-02-2019 10:20am
    Garda PR game has started - colm fox was now under huge pressure painting him as a victim.

    I find this startling as we have been force fed how experienced he was in these matters.
    Also gangland crime has a poor success rate in convicting people , if he followed the plan and nobody was tried or jailed then so be it, sometimes the evidence isn't there. Being such an experienced garda this would be standard fare to him and his superiors.

    something is afoot here.
    Whether it's garda corruption or even worse collusion with organised crime remains to be seen.
     
  • Registered Users Posts: 340 ✭✭ 22-02-2019 10:30am
    The other point to make is that the man could have been suffering from a mental illness which he hid and then combined with the stress of work/the trial, if he knew it was going to collapse, pushed him over the edge. On the outside looking in it may appear to be not enough to take your own life but when you live through extreme stress for a prolonged period it doesn’t take much for someone to snap, mental illness can effect anyone regardless of profession.
  •  
    MrFresh Closed Accounts Posts: 1,420 ✭✭✭
     
    Plus, what could be so compromising in the notes and USB stick.
    If there was a deliberate attempt to frame a suspect you would hardly put it down in your notes in an incriminating manner and leave a trail of evidence to it.
    If the notes incriminated him but he only realised it after the fact it would be a huge mistake but as you say, not the first and note the last.

    There's no suggestion the Ak47 was planted on Hutch, so, maybe I've seen too much TV, but would a cop be too bothered about a gang member's innocence on exact charges with stone wall evidence of serious criminality like that?
    He would have to have really taken it to heart re: that mistake causing the collapse of one of the biggest trials in the history of the state.
    Unless there's something much murkier going on...
    Those gangsters don't retire when they get away with a crime. He'd have just been focused on for the future crimes. There's nothing to indicate he was overly invested in the case.
    paw patrol wrote: »
    Garda PR game has started - colm fox was now under huge pressure painting him as a victim.

    I find this startling as we have been force fed how experienced he was in these matters.
    Also gangland crime as a poor success rate in convicting people , if he followed the plan and nobody was tried or jailed then so be it, sometimes the evidence isn't there. Being such an experienced garda this would be standard fare to him and his superiors.
    something is afoot here.
    Whether it's garda corruption or even worse collusion with organised crime remains to be seen.
    So you've completely ruled out any possibility that he is just one of the hundreds of people every year, mostly men, who find life to be too much? And you've completely discounted the fact that Garda suicide rates are about six times the national average.
  •  
    Chiparu Registered UsersPosts: 2,229 ✭✭✭
     
    I wonder is there evidence that there was a common practice to collude in the identification of suspects on CCTV? Could other cases be similarly tainted?
    If so, I expect this will be buried.  
    odyssey06 Registered Users Posts: 19,299 ✭✭✭✭
     
    Those gangsters don't retire when they get away with a crime. He'd have just been focused on for the future crimes. There's nothing to indicate he was overly invested in the case...
    So you've completely ruled out any possibility that he is just one of the hundreds of people every year, mostly men, who find life to be too much? And you've completely discounted the fact that Garda suicide rates are about six times the national average.
    Completely ruled out no, but how many of those Gardai left suicide notes that cause the collapse of trials? That suggests it was more than just finding life too much. There was a specific angle to the trial.
    Also, Garda suicide rates being 6 times the national average could be distorted somewhat by having a demographic 'bulge' in the gender and age profile at highest risk.
    That said, Colm Fox was in one of the highest risk profile, middle aged men.

    "To follow knowledge like a sinking star..." (Tennyson's Ulysses)  

    MrFresh Closed Accounts Posts: 1,420 ✭✭✭
     
    Completely ruled out no, but how many of those Gardai left suicide notes that cause the collapse of trials? That suggests it was more than just finding life too much. There was a specific angle to the trial.

    Also, Garda suicide rates being 6 times the national average could be distorted somewhat by having a demographic 'bulge' in the gender and age profile at highest risk.
    That said, Colm Fox was in one of the highest risk profile, middle aged men.
    Where are you getting the idea his suicide note collapsed the trial and not simply his death in itself?
  •  
    hatrickpatrickRegistered UsersPosts: 17,796 ✭✭✭✭
     
    Where are you getting the idea his suicide note collapsed the trial and not simply his death in itself?
    It was widely reported in the media at the time that the notes he wrote pertained directly to the trial and presented "unprecedented conundrums" which would have to be sorted out (the trial judge's own words). He then adjourned the trial while GSOC examined the notes and the circumstances around his death, including seizing electronic devices which had belonged to him and some of his colleagues.

    https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/regency-trial-adjourned-after-late-investigating-detective-s-notes-handed-in-1.3401701
    It's very clear that this pertained directly to the detective's notes.
    The Regency Hotel shooting trial has been adjourned for a month to allow the completion of an investigation into the circumstances of the death of Detective Supt Colm Fox, who had been the lead investigator into the fatal shooting.
    Notes written by the late garda were handed into the Special Criminal Court on Thursday and read by the three judges.
    The trial had been adjourned on Monday after the non-jury court heard that material in the case had presented some “unprecedented conundrums”.
    This was after an earlier adjournment, almost two weeks ago, when the defence requested to be provided with copies of emails exchanged between four gardaí involved in the case.
    And
    Prosecuting counsel Seán Gillane SC on Thursday asked the court to receive and read some material, which was not opened to the court. This material was “notes authored by the late superintendent”.

    Mr Gillane said these would “provide context” for the court regarding an application he would make. The court rose and the three judges read the notes.
    When the judges returned, Mr Gillane said there was a separate investigation ongoing into the “circumstances of Colm Fox’s passing”.
    “It’s felt having considered the matter carefully, it would be safer from everyone’s perspective to allow the investigation be completed before the trial will proceed,” he said.
    Mr Gillane added that an adjournment seemed to be the “safest path forward, to make sure no-one is taken by surprise by anything”.
    Michael O’Higgins SC, for Mr Hutch, said he had no objection to the trial being adjourned. Previously, he told the court the defence would be applying to have the trial “adjourned outright”.
    Subsequently:
    https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/courts/end-is-in-sight-for-inquiry-into-death-of-lead-garda-in-regency-case-court-hears-37277327.html
    Det Supt Fox died in February this year while the trial was in progress. The defence has since been given a copy of an interim report on the investigation into his death and the court was today told about progress being made on analyses of a mobile phone, laptop computer and two USB devices.

    This morning, prosecutor Sean Gillane said an end to "the IT end of the investgation" was in sight. One of the devices had been accessed and it generated a "fairly significant amount of material."

    Further examination of e-mails had been done and that analysis was near completion, he said.
    Why would they go to such lengths to break into electronic devices and recover data from them in this way if the suicide note wasn't directly relevant to the trial? Occam's Razor suggests that he wrote something very explosive or at least out of left field which threw the whole trial into chaos. GSOC then analysed his electronics and those of some of his colleagues, prepared a report on what they found during that investigation, and it was on foot of this report that the trial collapsed.
    It's very obvious at least to me that there's far, far more to this case than a Garda merely being overworked, and a trial stalling simply because he happened to be the lead investigator. Any speculation which does not tie these events together intrinsically is in my view a far more complicated and unlikely explanation than the obvious one - that this entire sequence of events was linked. The trial being adjourned over the photo identification, the photo being ruled admissible, the superintendent taking his own life less than a week later, and the trial subsequently collapsing on foot of his notes and an analysis of his and his colleagues communications.
    Unless there are other major elements here which have not been disclosed to the public, it seems like a very obvious logical conclusion that the above described sequence of events occured as a chain of cause and effect, not as individual events which just happened to occur in that order, in that time period. Something he wrote led to the judge getting spooked and adjourning the trial to wait for GSOC's analysis. Something GSOC found led them to delve deep into his electronic devices, and something they found during that investigation irreparably damaged the prosecution's case against Patrick Hutch.
  •  
    MrFresh Closed Accounts Posts: 1,420 ✭✭✭ 22-02-2019 6:31pm
    It was widely reported in the media at the time that the notes he wrote pertained directly to the trial and presented "unprecedented conundrums" which would have to be sorted out (the trial judge's own words). He then adjourned the trial while GSOC examined the notes and the circumstances around his death, including seizing electronic devices which had belonged to him and some of his colleagues.
    https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/regency-trial-adjourned-after-late-investigating-detective-s-notes-handed-in-1.3401701

    It's very clear that this pertained directly to the detective's notes.
    And
    Subsequently:
    https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/courts/end-is-in-sight-for-inquiry-into-death-of-lead-garda-in-regency-case-court-hears-37277327.html

    Why would they go to such lengths to break into electronic devices and recover data from them in this way if the suicide note wasn't directly relevant to the trial? Occam's Razor suggests that he wrote something very explosive or at least out of left field which threw the whole trial into chaos. GSOC then analysed his electronics and those of some of his colleagues, prepared a report on what they found during that investigation, and it was on foot of this report that the trial collapsed.
    It's very obvious at least to me that there's far, far more to this case than a Garda merely being overworked, and a trial stalling simply because he happened to be the lead investigator. Any speculation which does not tie these events together intrinsically is in my view a far more complicated and unlikely explanation than the obvious one - that this entire sequence of events was linked. The trial being adjourned over the photo identification, the photo being ruled admissible, the superintendent taking his own life less than a week later, and the trial subsequently collapsing on foot of his notes and an analysis of his and his colleagues communications.
    Unless there are other major elements here which have not been disclosed to the public, it seems like a very obvious logical conclusion that the above described sequence of events occured as a chain of cause and effect, not as individual events which just happened to occur in that order, in that time period. Something he wrote led to the judge getting spooked and adjourning the trial to wait for GSOC's analysis. Something GSOC found led them to delve deep into his electronic devices, and something they found during that investigation irreparably damaged the prosecution's case against Patrick Hutch.
    So Occam's Razor is your smoking gun? You're making your own story out of little to no actual facts. Of course there are major elements that have not been disclosed to the public. Practically nothing has. 
  •  
    hatrickpatrick Registered Users Posts: 17,796 ✭✭✭✭
     
    So Occam's Razor is your smoking gun? You're ma king your own story out of little to no actual facts. Of course there are major elements that have not been disclosed to the public. Practically nothing has.
    Well what do you regard as a more likely explanation given everything I've posted above from news articles written at the time of the events occurring (as opposed to summaries written this week)? Do you reckon that the series of events directly related to the defence's case in this trial happened one after the other and in close proximity to each other, entirely by chance?
    Why would the GSOC report be relevant to the trial and why would it be immediately after its presentation to both legal teams that the charges would be dropped, unless it's directly related?
    Correlation isn't causation, but there's a lot of correlation going on here.
  •  
    MrFresh Closed Accounts Posts: 1,420 ✭✭✭ 22-02-2019 8:05pm
    Well what do you regard as a more likely explanation given everything I've posted above from news articles written at the time of the events occurring (as opposed to summaries written this week)? Do you reckon that the series of events directly related to the defence's case in this trial happened one after the other and in close proximity to eachother, entirely by chance?

    Why would the GSOC report be relevant to the trial and why would it be immediately after its presentation to both legal teams that the charges would be dropped, unless it's directly related?

    Correlation isn't causation, but there's a lot of correlation going on here.
    GSOC's report is relevant because it's an investigation into the death of a primary witness. You're assuming that the case collapsed because of something in the report. But it could just have easily been something else and they held out for the GSOC report for procedural reasons.
     
  •  odyssey 06Registered UsersPosts: 19,299 ✭✭✭✭
    GSOC's report is relevant because it's an investigation into the death of a primary witness. You're assuming that the case collapsed because of something in the report. But it could just have easily been something else and they held out for the GSOC report for procedural reasons.

    Unlikely. If he had died in a car crash would trial have collapsed? No.
    There was something in the notes, or something in his conduct that demanded answers, over and above what he would typically have done.

    "To follow knowledge like a sinking star..." (Tennyson's Ulysses) 

    MrsmumRegistered UsersPosts: 1,860 ✭✭✭ 22-02-2019 8:22pm
    Just a thought - is it not very unusual for a person to take their own life at work while all other employees around them are working away? I wonder is there any message in that.
  •  
    MrFreshClosed AccountsPosts: 1,420 ✭✭✭
     
    Unlikely. If he had died in a car crash would trial have collapsed? No.
    What are you basing that on? If he was the only one that could testify to the full chain of custody for an important piece of evidence then it very well could have. 
     
    Edgware Registered UsersPosts: 5,875 ✭✭✭ 22-02-2019 8:34pm
    odyssey06 wrote: »
    Unlikely. If he had died in a car crash would trial have collapsed? No.
    There was something in the notes, or something in his conduct that demanded answers, over and above what he would typically have done.
    If his evidence was vital to the trial and he died any way of course the trial would collapse.
    The Defence are entitled to examine every witness. Being dead doesnt allow evidence to be admitted unchallenged. Why do you think witnesses are intimidated or killed?

    There are too many Lionel Hutz standard lawyers on this site who havent a clue about very basic rules of evidence.
    It’s a difficult dilemna for the journalists particularly the ones that cover gangland as a lot of their info is fed to them by the police so what do they do when it’s the guards themselves that are under the microscope, it would take an incredibly brave one to step up as they are burning their relationships but at the end of the day didn’t they go to journalist school to get to the truth no matter the barriers, I’m doubtful though, I think a lot of the journos are too close to the police for the truth to come out.
    Yeah, it's worth remembering that the journalists who really advanced and investigated the Maurice McCabe scandal were non-crime journalists like Katie Hannon and Mick Clifford - people who don't ordinarily rely upon AGS for their sources.
    Pauls Williams & Cunningham were, at best, unhelpful towards uncovering of the truth in that case
    If anything emerges from this story which reflects badly on AGS, I bet you a Supermacs meal deal, it won't come from a crime journalist
  •  
    odyssey06Registered UsersPosts: 19,299 ✭✭✭✭ 22-02-2019 9:00pm
    Edgware wrote: »
    If his evidence was vital to the trial and he died any way of course the trial would collapse.
    The Defence are entitled to examine every witness. Being dead doesnt allow evidence to be admitted unchallenged. Why do you think witnesses are intimidated or killed?
    There are too many Lionel Hutz standard lawyers on this site who havent a clue about very basic rules of evidence.
    Do you have a common law precedent for the absolute inadmissability of evidence if the death of a witness occurs - rather than withdrawal or refusal to tesifty?
    Mr Justice Tony Hunt, presiding, had already ruled that the images should be admitted as evidence. Opportunity to cross examine the chain of that evidence had already passed.
    This is being reported in the media specifically that the case collapsed because: "He [Fox] had left notes about the case that he could not be questioned about in court and so the trial process could go no further."
    https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/photos-were-key-evidence-in-hutch-trial-but-did-not-cause-case-to-collapse-1.3800840
    If he had not left notes and just died in a car crash, the trial process would have continued.

    "To follow knowledge like a sinking star..." (Tennyson's Ulysses) 

    The Satanist Closed AccountsPosts: 693 ✭✭✭
     
    It seems to me, at least, unusual that the defence would request those emails relating to identifying who was in that photo - why would they even suspect that there was an email trail? Surely that points to being tipped off that something was up? I mean, if your going to conspire with colleagues to make sure they ID someone, why email them, they're probably in the office beside you, no?

    Also, Patrick Hutch was only ever arrested once before this. His face would surely be virtually unknown, especially in Ballymun Garda station because he wasn't from there. From the photos I've seen of him in the media, versus that photo of the man dressed as a woman, I could not say with any certainty at all that it was the same person.
  •  
    MrFreshClosed AccountsPosts: 1,420 ✭✭✭
     
    odyssey06 wrote: »
    Do you have a common law precedent for the absolute inadmissability of evidence if the death of a witness occurs - rather than withdrawal or refusal to tesifty?
    Mr Justice Tony Hunt, presiding, had already ruled that the images should be admitted as evidence. Opportunity to cross examine the chain of that evidence had already passed.
    This is being reported in the media specifically that the case collapsed because: "He [Fox] had left notes about the case that he could not be questioned about in court and so the trial process could go no further."
    https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/photos-were-key-evidence-in-hutch-trial-but-did-not-cause-case-to-collapse-1.3800840

    If he had not left notes and just died in a car crash, the trial process would have continued.
    But your assumption is that his note revealed something new when it might also be that it contained some kind of affirmation of his given statements that he hoped would be accepted as a kind of dying declaration and his evidence would be accepted on the basis of it.

    People are assuming something in the case pushed him to suicide when it might also be that he had been holding off on killing himself until the case was over and he simply gave up.

    Then there is the other posters assumption that he did it in work as some kind of message where it is much more likely he did it there so he would be found fast by Gardaí rather than at home where he would be found by family. He's certainly not the first Garda to have done so. 
  •  
    odyssey06odyssey06Registered UsersPosts: 19,299 ✭✭✭✭
     
    MrFresh wrote: »
    But your assumption is that his note revealed something new when it might also be that it contained some kind of affirmation of his given statements that he hoped would be accepted as a kind of dying declaration and his evidence would be accepted on the basis of it.
    People are assuming something in the case pushed him to suicide when it might also be that he had been holding off on killing himself until the case was over and he simply gave up.
    Then there is the other posters assumption that he did it in work as some kind of message where it is much more likely he did it there so he would be found fast by Gardaí rather than at home where he would be found by family. He's certainly not the first Garda to have done so.
    I'm assuming it is because the case collapsed and the reason given is because of the information in the notes.
    If it was the reasons you suggest, the case would have collapsed and the reason given because key prosecution witness now unavailable and his evidence could not be admitted. There would no need to mention or comment on any notes in relation to the trial.
    Plus, this isn't a case where Fox was the sole witness and it is his word against the defendants and the witness has not yet been cross examined.

    The evidence against Hutch are (a) the photos - already admitted, and (b) what was obtained on foot of the warrant. Surely Fox wouldn't be the only person who could testify to (b)?

    So unless there is something new and specific in the notes to the case I am not seeing the reason yet why Fox's unavailability causes case to collapse.
    The case was weighing so heavily on Fox's mind that in his last acts he left notes specifically relating to the trial - but you assume the case had nothing to do with pushing him to suicide?

    "To follow knowledge like a sinking star..." (Tennyson's Ulysses) 

    MrFreshClosed AccountsPosts: 1,420 ✭✭✭
     
    odyssey06 wrote: »
    I'm assuming it is because the case collapsed and the reason given is because of the information in the notes.
    If it was the reasons you suggest, the case would have collapsed and the reason given because key prosecution witness now unavailable and his evidence could not be admitted. There would no need to mention or comment on any notes in relation to the trial.

    Plus, this isn't a case where Fox was the sole witness and it is his word against the defendants and the witness has not yet been cross examined.
    The evidence against Hutch are (a) the photos - already admitted, and (b) what was obtained on foot of the warrant. Surely Fox wouldn't be the only person who could testify to (b)?
    So unless there is something new and specific in the notes to the case I am not seeing the reason yet why Fox's unavailability causes case to collapse.

    The case was weighing so heavily on Fox's mind that in his last acts he left notes specifically relating to the trial - but you assume the case had nothing to do with pushing him to suicide?
    I've no doubt it contributed to the overall pressure he was under. You think it was weighing on his mind so much he felt the need to kill himself and write notes about it. I think it's more like he reached the end of his tether and tried to cause as little collateral damage as possible when he killed himself. The notes were intended to assist the prosecution in his absence.
    As to the collapse of the trial, the prosecution said "Sadly, the passing of Det Supt Colm Fox has resulted in a situation where the prosecution is not in a position to lead evidence on a number of evidential topics". That doesn't seem to support your claim. I think you vastly underestimate the level of proof required in a criminal trial. Every person who handled a piece of evidence must be able to give testimony to say it was not interfered with. Every conversation related to the detention and questioning must be supported by testimony. Every decision made must be justified. Every minute of the accused was detained in the Garda Station must have had cause and the lead investigator is the one to justify it. Others might be able to give snippets or support certain actions but only the lead investigator will have the full picture. Garda A can say he handed evidence to Fox and Garda B can say he received it from him but neither can say he didn't interfere with it or leave it somewhere unattended. So the chain of evidence is broken.
     
     
  •  
    paw patrolpaw patrol Registered Users Posts: 2,314 ✭✭✭
     
    MrFresh wrote: »

    So you've completely ruled out any possibility that he is just one of the hundreds of people every year, mostly men, who find life to be too much? And you've completely discounted the fact that Garda suicide rates are about six times the national average.
    pretty much as his final note spoke of an error of judgement which would indicate it was something specific driving it.
      
    professore Closed Accounts Posts: 5,857 ✭✭✭
     
    dundalkfc10 wrote: »
    She left at 17 many years ago when she fell pregnant first (ran away basically so her parents wouldn’t make her get rid) and returned in 1990 when getting a good job in Dundalk.
    It’s a horrible country to live in. I live with my girlfriend both earning 30,000 (I work every Sat aswell overtime to reach 30,000) with 1 kid. We have less disposable income than our neighbours who neither have a job, HAP pay there house, free childcare, free prams etc off the social etc...
    Then you see scum like this clown laughing at us after murdering someone as he walks free
    And free legal aid too 
  •  
    MrFresh Closed AccountsPosts: 1,420 ✭✭✭
     
    paw patrol wrote: »
    pretty much as his final note spoke of an error of judgement which would indicate it was something specific driving it.
    Can you post the transcript of that note? 
  •  
    joe swansonRegistered UsersPosts: 1,124 ✭✭✭
     
    Some pretty horrendous posts on here . A decent man is dead and people are speculating on why he would end his own life and casting aspersions on his character without knowing any facts, just speculating. It's pretty low and disgusting. Thread should close.
     
  •  
    odyssey06odyssey06Registered UsersPosts: 19,299 ✭✭✭✭
     
    MrFresh wrote: »
    As to the collapse of the trial, the prosecution said "Sadly, the passing of Det Supt Colm Fox has resulted in a situation where the prosecution is not in a position to lead evidence on a number of evidential topics". That doesn't seem to support your claim. I think you vastly underestimate the level of proof required in a criminal trial. Every person who handled a piece of evidence must be able to give testimony to say it was not interfered with. Every conversation related to the detention and questioning must be supported by testimony. Every decision made must be justified. Every minute of the accused was detained in the Garda Station must have had cause and the lead investigator is the one to justify it. Others might be able to give snippets or support certain actions but only the lead investigator will have the full picture. Garda A can say he handed evidence to Fox and Garda B can say he received it from him but neither can say he didn't interfere with it or leave it somewhere unattended. So the chain of evidence is broken.
    It didn't take 1 year since Fox's death to come to that conclusion. The prosecution would have been abandoned straight away if that was the real reason.
    Nothing changed in 12 months, Fox still wasn't there to lead evidence.
    What changed utterly was...
    February 7th 2018, the court was told what was being sought was disclosure of e-mails between four gardai involved in the case.
    Michael O’Higgins SC, defending, explained an issue had arisen in relation to garda statements, matters that were omitted and new statements that came together and “hit every single note on the scale."

    On Saturday, February 10, 2018 senior investigator in the case Det Supt Colm Fox was found dead at Ballymun Garda Station. His official firearm was recovered at the scene, foul play was not suspected and it was treated as a personal tragedy.
    The following Tuesday, February 13, Judge Hunt adjourned the case again after being told of Det Sgt Fox’s death.
    On February, 19, 2018 Mr O’Higgins said new material had been provided which he needed more time to consider. The material had presented “unprecedented conundrums” for the prosecution, Sean Gillane SC, prosecuting, said.

    "To follow knowledge like a sinking star..." (Tennyson's Ulysses)

  •  
    MrFreshClosed AccountsPosts: 1,420 ✭✭✭
     
    odyssey06 wrote: »
    It didn't take 1 year since Fox's death to come to that conclusion. The prosecution would have been abandoned straight away if that was the real reason.
    Nothing changed in 12 months, Fox still wasn't there to lead evidence.

    What changed utterly was...
    February 7th 2018, the court was told what was being sought was disclosure of e-mails between four gardai involved in the case.
    Michael O’Higgins SC, defending, explained an issue had arisen in relation to garda statements, matters that were omitted and new statements that came together and “hit every single note on the scale."

    On Saturday, February 10, 2018 senior investigator in the case Det Supt Colm Fox was found dead at Ballymun Garda Station. His official firearm was recovered at the scene, foul play was not suspected and it was treated as a personal tragedy.

    The following Tuesday, February 13, Judge Hunt adjourned the case again after being told of Det Sgt Fox’s death.

    On February, 19, 2018 Mr O’Higgins said new material had been provided which he needed more time to consider. The material had presented “unprecedented conundrums” for the prosecution, Sean Gillane SC, prosecuting, said.


    Right, the conundrum of whether a suicide note could be given any evidential value or whether additional evidence could be found to support what was in the note.
     
  •  
    odyssey06odyssey06Registered UsersPosts: 19,299 ✭✭✭✭
     
    joe swanson wrote: »
    Some pretty horrendous posts on here . A decent man is dead and people are speculating on why he would end his own life and casting aspersions on his character without knowing any facts, just speculating. It's pretty low and disgusting. Thread should close.

    I've no idea if he was or was not a decent man, not sure what aspersions have been cast here on his character to compare to:
    A senior counsel in open court has effectively accused him of participation in a miscarriage of justice in a murder trial.
    GSOC are officially investigating that "the circumstances giving rise to the death of the late Det Supt Fox".

    But yeah, attempt to shut down debate on an internet forum.

    "To follow knowledge like a sinking star..." (Tennyson's Ulysses) 

    Cee-Jay-Cee Registered Users Posts: 12,239 ✭✭✭✭
     
    Two detectives not witnesses! Even the reporters are saying there's a lot more to come out, to say he got aquitted just because of ID is naive. The longer gardai stay quite the more rumours will follow as to why.
    Typical of the ridiculous manner which AGS treats the media. In every other country in the world they have press releases where they provide info to prevent speculation and rumour. Here they say nothing and when they do it’s usually the usual shíte line of we don’t comment on cases. AGS need to come out if the dark ages and speak up for themselves but it’ll never change unril the promotion system of only promoting those who lick arse continues.
     

    The story of a feud: How the Kinahan-Hutch war escalated

    Fears that gun violence will ramp up after killing on Michael Keogh on Wednesday

    The story of a feud: How the Kinahan-Hutch war escalated – The Irish Times

    Gerry Hutch (aka the Monk) and Christy Kinahan. The gun feud between the two families began at a frantic pace before easing. Now Dublin is braced once more.

    Conor Lally's face

     Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch seen enjoying beer at Canary Island bar months before his arrest over Regency Hotel attack | The Irish Sun (thesun.ie)

    'The Monk' was drinking at Dicey Reillys bar in Lanzarote

 'The Monk' was drinking at Dicey Reillys bar in Lanzarote

And just like the clothes he was wearing when he was nabbed by Spanish police in Fuengirola one week ago, Hutch has a bum bag and sandals on.

Gardai believe he kept his ­Spanish identity card in the bag and his passport to help him ­disappear at short notice.

Although enjoying a bottle of beer, a glass of water can also be seen beside his seat. Investigators believe he only enjoyed a few beers and drank water and was never intoxicated over fears he may have had to leave a bar at short notice.

Our picture also shows that his hair is shorter and that he had grown a moustache.

It’s the first time a picture has been published showing Hutch when he was on the run.

Although the Dubliner escaped a Kinahan cartel hit team led by killer Eamonn Cumberton after they stormed a bar in Lanzarote looking for him, he had no ­problem returning to the island when he was on the run.

The image also showed how The Monk mingled alongside other customers without a care in the world.

And while the veteran criminal had managed to avoid the media during his time in exile, he had no idea his image had been taken as he drank in the bar.

As with his arrest in Spain last week, Hutch was in the company of a woman.

One punter told us: “We couldn’t believe it when we saw him and he was clearly enjoying himself.

“We knew who it was straight away and he just looked like any other tourist.”

'COULDN'T BELIEVE IT'

They added: “For someone who considers himself to be extremely street-wise he had no idea his image was being taken.

“He was just like any other ­tourist and didn’t look like someone who was on the run from the ­Gardai and under threat.”

Our exclusive image was taken when Hutch was staying at an apartment in the Tias area of ­Lanzarote in the Canaries.

But he’s believed to have fled from the island, which is off the west coast of Africa, after it emerged in April of this year that a European Arrest Warrant had been issued for his capture.

Gardai suspect he may have fled to ­Eastern Europe and received ­support from organised networks operating in the region.

ISLAND LIVING

But Hutch then made the mistake of returning to mainland Spain over the last two weeks despite having the arrest warrant hanging over him.

Investigators believe he returned to Spain because he had business interests there and also access to cash in various bank accounts.

Hutch had been staying at an apartment in Fuengirola’s Plaza de la Constitution area.

During his time in Lanzarote, The Monk is also believed to have travelled to Turkey and stayed at a beachfront villa in the Mahmutlar area of Alanya in Turkey.

KINAHAN ASSOCIATIONS

We can also reveal that financial investigators in Spain will be examining his financial dealings in the country to establish how much wealth he had access to.

Hutch has a lengthy association with the tourist island going back to the time when he remained a key associate and friend of Christy ‘Dapper Don’ Kinahan.

During his time on the sunshine island, he regularly welcomed members of the Kinahan cartel and their relatives.

And those who travelled to Lanzarote over the years included Freddie Thompson.

Others included Hutch’s nephew Gareth, who was later shot dead by Kinahan cartel killers Jonathan Keogh, Regina Keogh and Thomas Fox.

But Hutch’s relationship with senior ­members of the Kinahan cartel was shattered when his nephew Gary was shot dead in Mijas, Spain, in September, 2015.

'CENTRE OF ATTENTION'

A senior source told the Irish Sun: “Gerry Hutch always loved to be the centre of attention in ­Lanzarote and he liked nothing more than inviting his friends from Dublin to the island.

“His guests included senior ­members of the Kinahan cartel because they were all once friends and part of the same group.

“But as soon as his nephew Gary was killed their relationships would never be the same again.”

Following that killing, Hutch survived an attempt on his life when hitman Cumberton and another contract killer were dispatched to the island to take out their enemy in December 2015.

On that occasion, Hutch spotted the killers entering the bar and managed to escape.

Just two months later, cartel member David Byrne was shot dead at the Regency Hotel in Whitehall, Dublin.

At present, Hutch is being held at a high security prison in Madrid following his arrest.

He appeared in court in the Spanish capital last Saturday for a “preliminary hearing” and for him to be informed of the nature of the warrant he was arrested on.

HIGH SECURITY HOLD UP

But gardai are still waiting to hear from Spain about his next court appearance.

It’s understood that officials will then outline whether or not Hutch intends to fight his extradition to Ireland.

If he does, the court process in Spain could take months.

Our revelation of The Monk’s life on the run comes after Spanish police released footage of his arrest in a restaurant last week.

The video showed undercover cops disguised as tourists walking up to his table as he sat with a woman in the eatery.

He was then placed in handcuffs and brought to a toilet before his papers were examined by the arrest team.

Once examined, the Irish ­fugitive was then brought to a waiting car.

A Garda officer was also present as the Spanish ­investigators moved in.
In a statement issued by the Guardia Civil, they said: “According to the garda, the detainee was part of the Kinahan family crime gang, which was dedicated to criminality in Ireland and on Spain’s Costa del Sol.”

The Spanish police force added: “After an internal dispute, there was a split and another criminal group led by the now detained (Gerry Hutch) emerged, starting a fierce war between clans that has led to about 20 deaths from both sides between Ireland and Spain.”

Hutch during his arrest

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch during his arrest

Freddie Thompson has also went on holidays in Lanzarote

Freddie Thompson has also went on holidays in Lanzarote

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch enjoying a drunk in a bar in Lanzarote

 Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch seen enjoying beer at Canary Island bar months before his arrest over Regency Hotel attack | The Irish Sun (thesun.ie)

 

The Monk's Life In Exile

 
 

A secret tape and firearms training: how the evidence is stacking up against Gerry Hutch

The Monk is set to face the most serious charge of his criminal career

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch
 

The news that Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch is to face a murder charge arising from the Regency Hotel attack has come as a major surprise to many.

The fact that a European Arrest Warrant was issued for his apprehension for the murder of drug dealer David Byrne – as exclusively revealed by the Irish Independent

 

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch: Life and crimes of the 'Golden Gangster'

First in the dock at the age of eight, he went on to rob around €14 million

 

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch: Life and crimes of the 'Golden Gangster' - Buzz.ie

Gerry-Hutch

Gerry "The Monk" Hutch

Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch was this week found not guilty of the murder of David Byrne in the Regency Hotel — and is now a free man.

In dramatic scenes, Hutch (60) walked straight out the front doors of the Central Criminal Courts in Dublin’s Parkgate Street. 

It came after the non-jury Special Criminal Court found him not guilty of the Kinahan cartel associate’s murder.

Buzz.ie looks back on The Monk's life and crimes...

The early years

Gerard Hutch was just a kid when he had his first run-in with the law.

Born to parents Patrick and Julia Hutch in a flats complex on Foley Street in north inner city Dublin on April 11, 1963, Gerard — as he is still known by locals — first appeared in court in the city in November 1971 at the age of eight.

Most people today would be horrified that a child that age could actually be brought before the courts — but in the 1960s, the age of criminal responsibility was seven, compared to 12 today for most cases, while it is as young as 10 for crimes such as rape and murder.

But the young Gerry Hutch was brought before Dublin District Court for theft. He was given the benefit of the Probation Act, which meant he had no criminal conviction recorded against his name.

Between 1971 and 1978 when he turned 18, Hutch amassed more than 30 charges and convictions.

The convictions included crimes such as theft, assault, burglary, joy riding and criminal damage.

He was locked up 10 times, mostly short-term sentences in the now closed St Patrick’s Institution, but he also served in Dublin’s Mountjoy Prison.

Jailed

A nine-month sentence was imposed on him in 1978 for a number of crimes — and he served his time in an adult jail, even though he was only 15.

By then he had become heavily involved in a gang nicknamed the “Bugsy Malones” after the famous movie. The gang specialised in burglaries and jumpovers — robbing banks by leaping over the counters, grabbing whatever cash they could and then running.

The gang would also loiter at traffic lights and once they turned red, they would smash a car window with brick and grab whatever they could – like a handbag or briefcase – before scarpering.

Gerry Hutch

 

The 80s

In February 1981, gardai believe he was part of a gang that robbed a bank in central Dublin in which they got the equivalent of €350,000.

Unarmed gardai came across the gang, but one of them opened fire on their patrol car. Hutch was arrested over the robbery but was later released without charge.

In March 1981, gardai believe he and a pal carried out a robbery of a department store in central Dublin.

They used a motorbike. They escaped with the day’s takings, worth some €450,000 in today's money.

In November 1981, he was involved in another robbery in which the gang got some €25,000 in today’s money. Armed detectives later raided a house and recovered the cash and weapons used in the heist.

Gerry-The-Monk-Hutch

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch 

 

Hutch was confronted by two detectives, including Michael O’Sullivan who would later go on to be Assistant Garda Commissioner Michael O’Sullivan. Hutch was then arrested, but was not charged.

Hutch became a father for the first time at the age of 18 – and bought his first house on Buckingham Street in central Dublin.

Gardai suspect he kept up his robbery spree. It’s believed in February 1982 he dressed as a woman to carry out a robbery in central Dublin — where he shot and injured a security man before escaping with cash.

He’s suspected to have used the same disguise a year later in an attack in Sutton.

 

But that was nothing compared to the infamous Marino Mart robbery gardai believe he masterminded in January 1987 in central Dublin.

His gang got away with some €3.5 million — a heist that catapulted Hutch into the big time.

Gerry Hutch

Gerry Hutch walks free from court 

The 90s

In January 1992, he is suspected of overseeing the robbery of the equivalent of €5m from an AIB facility in Waterford.

Then in January 1995, his gang stole the modern equivalent of €5.5 million from the Brinks Allied depot in Clonshaugh, north Dublin.

All in all, investigators believe his gangs took more than €14m in robberies down the years.

The noughties

In the year 2000, he settled an investigation by the Criminal Assets Bureau and agreed to hand over the equivalent of €2.5m. Some of it he delivered in a money order, but he also carried some €500,000 of it in hard cash in a rucksack to a bank on Talbot Street in central Dublin — a moment The Star captured.

He won the right to secure a taxi licence after a court case in 2001 and in 2004 he hit headlines when he bought a stretch Hummer limousine for his chauffeur business.

Gerry Hutch-Irish Daily Star front page dubs Gerry Hutch the 'Golden Gangster' with 'The Midas Hutch'.jpg

Irish Daily Star front page dubs Gerry Hutch the 'Golden Gangster' with 'The Midas Hutch'

He enjoyed that job for a few years and rubbed shoulders with celebrities including Mike Tyson and Marvin Hagler, but he sold the vehicle when the recession hit after 2008.

Recent years

From then on he was enjoying life in semi-retirement in his Lanzarote bolthole, until an attempt on his life in 2016.

That came after the feud between the Kinahan cartel and Hutch mob had been sparked by a cold-blooded hit on Gary Hutch in Spain in 2015.

Now he has been dubbed 'The Golden Gangster' with 'The Midas Hutch' after he was found not guilty of the murder of David Byrne in the Regency Hotel in 2016.